Abstract
Trials in developed countries have shown that therapeutic hypothermia reduces the risk of death or severe disability in infants with neonatal encephalopathy. Cooling has been adopted as a standard of care in some parts of the world. Some Indian neonatal units have considered or even embarked upon cooling encephalopathic term newborn infants. In this article we discuss some of the potential ethical questions that should be considered before introducing therapeutic hypothermia in an Indian setting. Evidence from previous trials may not be relevant given significant differences in the epidemiology of neonatal encephalopathy in countries like India. There is a possibility that hypothermia would be ineffective or harmful. The most appropriate way to answer these concerns would be to perform a large randomized controlled trial of cooling in India. However, such trials will also raise potential ethical challenges. Cooling may also affect decisions about treatment withdrawal, and may create uncertainty about prognosis. It may exacerbate ethical problems relating to lack of neonatal intensive care bed space.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Eicher DJ, Wagner CL, Katikaneni LP, Hulsey TC, Bass WT, Kaufman DA, et al. Moderate hypothermia in neonatal encephalopathy: efficacy outcomes. Pediatr Neurol 2005;32:11–17.
Gluckman PD, Wyatt JS, Azzopardi D, Ballard R, Edwards AD, Ferriero DM, et al. Selective head cooling with mild systemic hypothermia after neonatal encephalopathy: multicentre randomised trial. Lancet 2005;365:663–670.
Shankaran S, Laptook AR, Ehrenkranz RA, Tyson JE, McDonald SA, Donovan EF, et al. Whole-body hypothermia for neonates with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. N Engl J Med 2005;353:1574–1584.
Azzopardi DV, Strohm B, Edwards AD, Dyet L, Halliday HL, Juszczak E, et al. Moderate hypothermia to treat perinatal asphyxial Encephalopathy. N Engl J Med 2009;361:1349–1358.
Edwards AD, Brocklehurst P, Gunn AJ, Halliday H, Juszczak E, Levene M, et al. Neurological outcomes at 18 months of age after moderate hypothermia for perinatal hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy: synthesis and meta-analysis of trial data. BMJ 2010;340:c363.
Jacobs S, Hunt R, Tarnow-Mordi W, Inder T, Davis P. Cooling for newborns with hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. Cochrane Database of Systematic Rev 2007;CD003311.
Shah P, Ohlsson A, Perlman M. Hypothermia to treat neonatal hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy: systematic review. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2007;161:951–958.
Azzopardi D, Strohm B, Edwards AD, Halliday H, Juszczak E, Levene M, et al. Treatment of asphyxiated newborns with moderate hypothermia in routine clinical practice: how cooling is managed in the UK outside a clinical trial. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2009;94:F 260–264.
Hoehn T, Hansmann G, Bührer C, Simbruner G, Gunn AJ, Yager J, et al. Therapeutic hypothermia in neonates. Review of current clinical data, ILCOR recommendations and suggestions for implementation in neonatal intensive care units. Resuscitation 2008;78:7–12.
Perlman M, Shah PS. Ethics of therapeutic hypothermia. Acta Paediatr 2009;98:211–213.
Kirpalani H, Barks J, Thorlund K, Guyatt G. Cooling for neonatal hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy: do we have the answer? Pediatrics 2007;120:1126–1130.
Perlman M, Shah P. Time to adopt cooling for neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy: response to a previous commentary. Pediatrics 2008;121:616–618.
Wilkinson DJ. Cool heads: ethical issues associated with therapeutic hypothermia for newborns. Acta Paediatrica. 2008;98:217–220.
Lantos J, Meadow W. Hot debate about a cool therapy. NeoReviews 2009;10:e65–e70.
Wilkinson DJ, Casalaz D, Watkins A, Andersen CC, Duke T. Hypothermia: a neuroprotective therapy for neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. Pediatrics 2007;422–423.
Robertson A. Reflections on errors in neonatology III. The “experienced” years, 1970 to 2000. J Perinatol 2003;23:240–249
Lau J, Schmid CH, Chalmers TC. Cumulative metaanalysis of clinical trials builds evidence for exemplary medical care. J Clin Epidemiol. 1995;48:45–57;9–60.
Chalmers I. The scandalous failure of science to cumulate evidence scientifically. Clin Trials 2005;2:229–231.
Kapetanakis A, Azzopardi D, Wyatt J, Robertson NJ. Therapeutic hypothermia for neonatal encephalopathy: a UK survey of opinion, practice and neuro-investigation at the end of 2007. Acta Paediatr 2009;98:631–635.
Thayyil S, Costello A, Shankaran S, Robertson NJ. Therapeutic hypothermia for neonatal encephalopathy: Implications for neonatal units in India. Indian Pediatr 2009;46:283–289.
Wilkinson D, Thayyil S, Robertson N. Ethical and practical issues relating to the global use of therapeutic hypothermia for newborn infants. Arch Dis Child 2010 (In press).
Ellis M, Manandhar N, Shrestha PS, Shrestha L, Manandhar DS, Costello AM. Outcome at 1 year of neonatal encephalopathy in Kathmandu, Nepal. Dev Med Child Neurol 1999;41:689–695.
Mathur NB, Krishnamurthy S, Mishra TK. Evaluation of WHO classification of hypothermia in sick extramural neonates as predictor of fatality. J Trop Pediatr 2005;51:341–345.
Thayyil S, Bhutta Z, Ramji S, Costello A, Robertson N. Global applications of therapeutic hypothermia to treat perinatal asphyxial encephalopathy. Int Health 2010 (In press).
Lawn J, Shibuya K, Stein C. No cry at birth: global estimates of intrapartum stillbirths and intrapartum-related neonatal deaths. Bulletin of the World Health Organ. 2005;83:409–417.
Gunn AJ, Gluckman PD. Head cooling for neonatal encephalopathy: the state of the art. Clin Obstet Gynecol 2007;50:636–651.
Kambarami R, Chidede O. Neonatal hypothermia levels and risk factors for mortality in a tropical country. Cent Afr J Med 2003;49:103–106.
Kumar V, Shearer JC, Kumar A, Darmstadt GL. Neonatal hypothermia in low resource settings: A review. J Perinatol 2009;29:401–412.
Wilkinson D. Therapeutic hypothermia and the ‘equal air-time’ solution for controversial randomised trials. J Paediatr Child Health 2010 (In press).
Snowdon C, Garcia J, Elbourne D. Making sense of randomization; responses of parents of critically ill babies to random allocation of treatment in a clinical trial. Soc Sci Med 1997;45:1337–1355.
Allmark P, Spedding M. Clinical trials in neonates: Ethical issues. Semin Fetal Neonatal Med 2007;12:318–323.
Weijer C, Shapiro SH, Cranley Glass K. For and against: clinical equipoise and not the uncertainty principle is the moral underpinning of the randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2000;321:756–758.
World Medical Association. ’Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles For Medical Research Involving Human Subjects 2008. Available from http://www.wma.net/e/policy/b3.htm. Accessed 4 December, 2008.
Hope RA. Medical ethics: a very short introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2004.
Wendler D, Emanuel EJ, Lie RK. The standard of care debate: can research in developing countries be both ethical and responsive to those countries’ health needs? Am J Public Health 2004;94:923–928.
Nuffield Council on Bioethics. The ethics of research related to healthcare in developing countries. London: Nuffield Council on Bioethics; 2002.
Pierrat V, Haouari N, Liska A, Thomas D, Subtil D, Truffert P, et al. Prevalence, causes, and outcome at 2 years of age of newborn encephalopathy: population based study. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2005; 90: F257–261
Verhagen A, Dorscheidt J, Engels B, Hubben J, Sauer P. End-of-life decisions in Dutch neonatal intensive care units. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2009;163:895–901.
Subramanian KN. Caring for newborns: three world views. In India, Nepal, and Sri Lanka, quality of life weights heavily. Hastings Cent Rep 1986;16:20–22.
Subramanian KN, Paul VK. Care of critically ill newborns in India. Legal and ethical issues. J Legal Med 1995;16:263–275.
Mani RK. End-of-life care in India. Intensive Care Med 2006;32:1066–1068.
Miljeteig I, Norheim OF. My job is to keep him alive, but what about his brother and sister? How Indian doctors experience ethical dilemmas in neonatal medicine. Dev World Bioethics 2006;6:23–32.
McHaffie HE, Fowlie PW. Life, death and decisions: Doctors and nurses reflect on neonatal practice. Hale: Hochland and Hochland 1996.
Wilkinson D. Death in the Netherlands: evidence and argument. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2009;163:958–959.
Wilkinson D. The window of opportunity: decision theory and the timing of prognostic tests for newborn infants. Bioethics 2009;23:503–514.
Gunn AJ, Wyatt JS, Whitelaw A, Barks J, Azzopardi D, Ballard R, et al. Therapeutic hypothermia changes the prognostic value of clinical evaluation of neonatal encephalopathy. J Pediatr 2008;152:55–58.
Hallberg B, Grossmann K, Bartocci M, Blennow M. The prognostic value of early EEG in asphyxiated infants undergoing systemic hypothermia treatment. Acta Paediatr 2010;99:531–536.
Rutherford M, Ramenghi LA, Edwards AD, Brocklehurst P, Halliday H, Levene M, et al. Assessment of brain tissue injury after moderate hypothermia in neonates with hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy: a nested substudy of a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Neurol 2010;9:39–45.
Miljeteig I, Sayeed SA, Jesani A, Johansson KA, Norheim OF. Impact of ethics and economics on end-of-life decisions in an Indian neonatal unit. Pediatrics 2009;124:e322–328.
Fairchild K, Sokora D, Scott J, Zanelli S. Therapeutic hypothermia on neonatal transport: 4-year experience in a single NICU. J Perinatol 2009 Oct 22 [Epub ahead of print]; doi: 10.1038/jp.2009.
Perlman JM. Hypothermia as a therapeutic intervention in term infants with neonatal encephalopathy-Is it ready for prime time? Resuscitation 2008;78:1–2.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wilkinson, D.J., Singh, M. & Wyatt, J. Ethical challenges in the use of therapeutic hypothermia in Indian neonatal units. Indian Pediatr 47, 387–393 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13312-010-0074-6
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13312-010-0074-6