Abstract
A scientific explanatory project, part-whole explanation, and a kind of science, part-whole science are premised on identifying, investigating, and using parts and wholes. In the biological sciences, mechanistic, structuralist, and historical explanations are part-whole explanations. Each expresses different norms, explananda, and aims. Each is associated with a distinct partitioning frame for abstracting kinds of parts. These three explanatory projects can be complemented in order to provide an integrative vision of the whole system, as is shown for a detailed case study: the tetrapod limb. My diagnosis of part-whole explanation in the biological sciences as well as in other domains exploring evolved, complex, and integrated systems (e.g., psychology and cognitive science) cross-cuts standard philosophical categories of explanation: causal explanation and explanation as unification. Part-whole explanation is itself one essential aspect of part-whole science.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barrett H. C., Kurzban R. (2006) Modularity in cognition: Framing the debate. Psychological Review 113: 628–647
Bechtel W., Richardson R.C. (1993) Discovering complexity. Decomposition and localization as strategies in scientific research. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Boogerd F. C., Bruggeman F. J., Richardson R. C., Stephan A., Westerhoff H. V. (2005) Emergence and its place in nature: A case study of biochemical networks. Synthese 145: 131–164
Boyd, R. (1999a). Kinds as the “workmanship of men”: Realism, constructivism, and natural kinds. In J. Nida-Rümelin (Ed.), Rationalität, realismus, revision: Proceedings of the third international congress, Gesellschaft für Analytische Philosophie (pp. 52–89). Berlin: de Gruyter.
Boyd R. (1999) Homeostasis, species, and higher taxa. In: Wilson R.A. (eds) Species. New interdisciplinary essays. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 141–185
Brigandt, I. (2009). Natural kinds in evolution and systematics: Metaphysical and epistemological considerations. (Vergara-Silva, F., & Winther, R. G., Eds.). Acta Biotheoretica, 57, 77–97.
Brooks R.A. (1997) Intelligence without representation. In: Haugeland J. (eds) Mind design II. Philosophy, psychology, artificial intelligence. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 395–420
Burke A. C., Feduccia A. (1997) Developmental patterns and the identification of homologies in the avian hand. Science 278: 666–668
Capdevila J., Izpisúa Belmonte J. C. (2001) Patterning mechanisms controlling vertebrate limb development. Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology 17: 87–132
Cartwright N. (1999) The dappled world. A study of the boundaries of science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Colless D. H. (1985) On “character” and related terms. Systematic Zoology 34: 229–233
Craver C. (2007) Explaining the brain. Mechanisms and the mosaic unity of neuroscience. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Crombie A.C. (1994) Styles of scientific thinking in the European tradition (3 Vols). Duckworth, London
Cummins R. (1975) Functional analysis. Journal of Philosophy 72: 741–765
Cummins R. (1983) The nature of psychological explanation. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Cummins R. (1999) “How does it work?” vs. “what are the laws?”: Two conceptions of psychological explanation. In: Keil F. C., Wilson R. A. (eds) Explanation and cognition. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 117–144
Dupré J. (1993) The disorder of things. Metaphysical foundations of the disunity of science. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Dupré J. (2002) Is ‘natural kind’ a natural kind term?. The Monist 85: 29–49
Emmeche C., Køppe S., Stjernfelt F. (1997) Explaining emergence: Towards an ontology of levels. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 28: 83–119
Feduccia A., Nowicki J. (2002) The hand of birds revealed by early ostrich embryos. Naturwissenschaften 89: 391–393
Forgacs G., Newman S.A. (2005) Biological physics of the developing embryo. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Friedman M. (1974) Explanation and scientific understanding. Journal of Philosophy 71: 5–19
Friedman M. (1983) Foundations of space-time theories. Relativistic physics and philosophy of science. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Galis F., Kundrát M., Metz J. A. J. (2005) Hox genes, digit identities, and the theropod/bird transition. Journal of Experimental Zoology. Part B. Molecular and Developmental Evolution 304B: 198–205
Gerstl P., Pribbenow S. (1995) Midwinters, end games, and body-parts: A classification of part-whole relations. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 43: 865–889
Gilbert S. F., Sarkar S. (2000) Embracing complexity: Organicism for the 21st century. Developmental Dynamics 219: 1–9
Ghiselin M. (1997) Metaphysics and the origin of species. State University of New York Press, Albany, NY
Ghiselin M. (2005) Homology as a relation of correspondence between parts of individuals. Theory in Biosciences 124: 91–103
Glennan S. (1996) Mechanisms and the nature of causation. Erkenntnis 44: 49–71
Glennan S. (2002) Rethinking mechanistic explanation. Philosophy of Science 69: S342–S353
Goodman N. (1978) Ways of worldmaking. Hackett Publishing Co, Indianapolis
Goodwin B. (1994) How the leopard changed its spots. The evolution of complexity. Simon & Shuster, New York
Goodwin B., Dawkins R. (1995) What is an organism?: A discussion. In: Thompson N. S. (eds) Perspectives in ethology. Volume 11: Behavioral design. Plenum Press, New York, pp 47–60
Gould, S. J. (1980). The panda’s thumb. In S. J. Gould (Ed.), The panda’s thumb. Reflections in natural history (pp. 19–26). New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Griffiths P.E. (1999) Squaring the circle: Natural kinds with historical essences. In: Wilson R.A. (eds) Species, New interdisciplinary essays. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 209–228
Guerrero McManus F. (2009) Rational disagreements in phylogenetics. (Vergara-Silva, F. & Winther, R. G., Eds.). Acta Biotheoretica 57: 99–127
Hacking I. (2002) Historical ontology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA
Hacking I. (2007) Natural kinds: Rosy dawn, scholastic twilight. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements 61: 203–240
Hacking I. (2009) Scientific reason. National Taiwan University Press, Taipei
Hall, B.K. (eds) (2007) Fins into limbs. Evolution, development, and transformation. University of Chicago Press,
Hall B.K. (2007) Introduction. In: Hall B.K. (eds) Fins into limbs. Evolution, development, and transformation. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 1–3
Halonen I., Hintikka J. (2005) Toward a theory of the process of explanation. Synthese 143: 5–61
Harfe B. D., Scherz P. J., Nissim S., Tian H., McMahon A. P., Tabin C. J. (2004) Evidence for an expansion-based temporal Shh gradient in specifying vertebrate digit identities. Cell 118: 517–528
Haugeland J. (1997) What is mind design?. In: Haugeland J. (eds) Mind design II. Philosophy, psychology, artificial intelligence. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 1–28
Haugeland J. (1998) The nature and plausibility of cognitivism (1978). In: Haugeland J. (eds) Having thought. Essays in the metaphysics of mind. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 9–45
Hentschel H. G. E., Glimm T., Glazier J. A., Newman S. A. (2004) Dynamical mechanisms for skeletal pattern formation in the vertebrate limb. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B 271: 1713–1722
Hull D. (1989) The metaphysics of evolution. State University of New York Press, Albany
Hull D. (1992) The particular-circumstance model of scientific explanation. In: Nitecki M. H., Nitecki D. V. (eds) History and evolution. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp 69–80
Kauffman, S. A. (1971). Articulation of parts explanation in biology and the rational search for them. In R. C. Buck & R. S. Cohen (Eds.), PSA 1970. (and Boston studies in the philosophy of science, Vol. 8) (pp. 257–272). Dordrecht: Reidel
Kauffman S.A. (1993) The origins of order. Self-organization and selection in evolution. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Kearney M., Rieppel O. (2006) Rejecting “the given” in systematics. Cladistics 22: 369–377
Khalidi M. A. (1998) Natural kinds and crosscutting categories. Journal of Philosophy 95: 33–50
Kitcher P. (1981) Explanatory unification. Philosophy of Science 48: 251–281
Levins R., Lewontin R.C. (1985) The dialectical biologist. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Lewontin R. C. (1969) The bases of conflict in biological explanation. Journal of the History of Biology 2: 35–45
Lewontin R. C. (2001) Foreword. In: Wagner G. P. (eds) The character concept in evolutionary biology. Academic Press, San Diego, pp xvii–xxiii
Lewontin R. C., Levins R. (2007) Biology under the influence. Dialectical essays on ecology, agriculture, and health. Monthly Review Press, New York
Longino H. (2001) The fate of knowledge. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Love, A. (2009). Typology reconfigured: From the metaphysics of essentialism to the epistemology of representation. (Vergara-Silva, F., & Winther, R. G., Eds.). Acta Biotheoretica, 57, 51–75.
Lovejoy C. O., McCollum M. A., Reno P. L., Rosenman B. A. (2003) Developmental biology and human evolution. Annual Review of Anthropology 32: 85–109
Machamer P., Darden L., Craver C. (2000) Thinking about mechanisms. Philosophy of Science 67: 1–25
Martínez S. F. (1992) Objetividad contextual y robustez. Diánoia 38: 143–152
Newman S. A., Müller G. B. (2000) Epigenetic mechanisms of character origination. Journal of Experimental Zoology. Part B. Molecular and Developmental Evolution 288: 304–317
Newman S. A., Müller G. B. (2005) Origination and innovation in the vertebrate limb skeleton: An epigenetic perspective. Journal of Experimental Zoology. Part B. Molecular and Developmental Evolution 304B: 593–609
Noë A. (2009) Out of our heads. Hill and Wang, New York
Oster G. F., Shubin N., Murray J. D., Alberch P. (1988) Evolution and morphogenetic rules: The shape of the vertebrate limb in ontogeny and phylogeny. Evolution 42: 862–884
Pinker S. (2005) So how does the mind work?. Mind and Language 20: 1–24
Radder H. (2006) The world observed/the world conceived. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh
Richards R. J. (1992) The structure of narrative explanation in history and biology. In: Nitecki M. H., Nitecki D. V. (eds) History and evolution. SUNY Press, Albany, NY, pp 19–53
Rieppel O. (1988) Fundamentals of comparative biology. Birkhauser Verlag AG, Basel, Switzerland
Rieppel O. (2001) Preformationist and epigenetic biases in the history of the morphological character concept. In: Wagner G. P. (eds) The character concept in evolutionary biology. Academic Press, San Diego, pp 57–75
Rieppel O., Kearney M. (2007) The poverty of taxonomic characters. Biology and Philosophy 22: 95–113
Salmon W. C. (1990) Four decades of scientific explanation. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
Sarkar S. (1992) Models of reduction and categories of reductionism. Synthese 91: 167–194
Shapin S. (1996) The scientific revolution. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Shubin N. H. (1994) History, ontogeny, and evolution of the archetype. In: Hall B. K. (eds) Homology: The hierarchical basis of comparative biology. Academic Press, San Diego, pp 249–271
Shubin N. H., Alberch P. (1986) A morphogenetic approach to the origin and basic organization of the tetrapod limb. Evolutionary Biology 20: 319–387
Simon H.A. (1962) The architecture of complexity. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 106: 467–482
Simons P. (1987) Parts. A study in ontology. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Smith B. (eds). (1987). Foundations of gestalt theory. Munich, Philosophia
Smith B., Varzi A. C. (1999) The niche. Noûs 33: 198–222
Smith L. B., Thelen E. (2003) Development as a dynamic system. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7: 343–348
Sober E. (1988) Reconstructing the past. Parsimony, evolution, and inference. MIT Press, Cambridge
Sober E. (2004) The contest between parsimony and likelihood. Systematic Biology 53: 644–653
Sober E. (2008) Evidence and evolution. The logic behind the science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Stjernfelt, F. (2007). Diagrammatology. An investigation on the borderlines of phenomenology, ontology, and semiotics. Synthese Library Vol. 336. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer.
Strevens M. (2004) The causal and unification accounts of explanation unified—causally. Noûs 38: 154–176
Tabery J. G. (2004) Synthesizing activities and interactions in the concept of a mechanism. Philosophy of Science 71: 1–15
Tanaka, M., & Tickle, C. (2007). The development of fins and limbs. In B. K. Hall (Ed.), Fins into limbs. Evolution, development, and transformation (pp. 65–78). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Thompson, D. ([1917] 1961). On growth and form. Abridged from 1917 edition by J. T. Bonner. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tickle C. (2003) Patterning systems—from one end of the limb to the other. Developmental Cell 4: 449–458
Tickle C. (2006) Making digit patterns in the vertebrate limb. Nature Reviews. Molecular Cell Biology 7: 45–53
Turing A. M. (1952) The chemical basis of morphogenesis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B 237: 37–72
van Fraassen B. (1980) The scientific image. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Vargas A. O., Wagner G. P. (2009) Frame-shifts of digit identity in bird evolution and cyclopamine-treated wings. Evolution and Development 11: 162–168
Vergara-Silva, F., & Winther, R. G. (Eds.). (2009). Symposium issue. Systematics, Darwinism, and the philosophy of science. Acta Biotheoretica 57(1–2), 1–307.
Wagner G. P. (2005) The developmental evolution of avian digit homology: An update. Theory in Biosciences 124: 165–183
Wagner G.P., Gauthier J.A. (1999) 1, 2, 3 = 2, 3, 4: A solution to the problem of the homology of the digits in the avian hand. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 96: 5111–5116
Wagner G.P., Larsson H.C.E. (2007) Fins and limbs in the study of evolutionary novelties. In: Hall B.K. (eds) Fins into limbs. Evolution, development, and transformation. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 49–61
Weatherbee S.D., Niswander L.A. (2007) Mechanisms of chondrogenesis and osteogenesis in limbs. In: Hall B.K. (eds) Fins into limbs. Evolution, development, and transformation. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 93–102
Webster G., Goodwin B. (1996) Form and transformation. Generative and relational principles in biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Winston M. E., Chaffin R., Herrmann D. (1987) A taxonomy of part-whole relations. Cognitive Science 11: 417–444
Wimsatt, W. C. (1974). Complexity and organization. In K. Schaffner & R. S. Cohen (Eds.), PSA 1972. (and Boston studies in the philosophy of science, Vol. 20) (pp. 67–86). Dordrecht: Reidel.
Wimsatt W.C. (2007) Re-engineering philosophy for limited beings. Piecewise approximations to reality. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Winther R. G. (2001) Varieties of modules: Kinds, levels, origins and behaviors. Journal of Experimental Zoology. Part B. Molecular and Developmental Evolution 291: 116–129
Winther R. G. (2006) Parts and theories in compositional biology. Biology and Philosophy 21: 471–499
Winther, R. G. (2007). Estilos de investigación científica, modelos e insectos sociales. In E. Suárez (Ed.), Variedad Infinita. Ciencia y representación. Un enfoque histórico y filosófico (pp. 55–89). Mexico City: UNAM and Editorial Limusa.
Winther R.G. (2008) Systemic Darwinism. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105: 11833–11838
Winther R. G. (2009a) Character analysis in cladistics: Abstraction, reification, and the search for objectivity. (Vergara-Silva, F. & Winther, R. G., Eds.). Acta Biotheoretica 57: 129–162
Winther, R. G. (2009b). Schaffner’s model of theory reduction: Critique and reconstruction. Philosophy of Science, 76.
Winther, R. G. (forthcoming a). Prediction in selectionist evolutionary theory. Philosophy of Science, 76.
Winther, R. G. (forthcoming b). Teorías, prácticas y estilos de investigación científica. In S. Martínez, X. Huang, & G. Guillaumin (Eds.), Filosofía de las prácticas científicas. Hacia una filosofía de la ciencia no centrada en teorías. Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana.
Wolpert L. (1969) Positional information and the spatial pattern of cellular differentiation. Journal of Theoretical Biology 25: 1–47
Woodger J. H. (1945) On biological transformations. In: Le Gros Clark W. E., Medawar P. B. (eds) Growth and form. Essays presented to D’Arcy Thompson. Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp 95–120
Woodward J. (2003) Making things happen. A theory of causal explanation. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Zhu J., Zhang Y. T., Newman S. A., Alber M. (2009) Application of discontinuous Galerkin methods for reaction-diffusion systems in developmental biology. Journal of Scientific Computing 40: 391–418
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Winther, R.G. Part-whole science. Synthese 178, 397–427 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9647-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9647-0