Abstract
This paper examines parents’ experiences of medical decision-making and coping with having a critically ill baby in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) from a cross-cultural perspective (France vs. U.S.A.). Though parents’ experiences in the NICU were very similar despite cultural and institutional differences, each system addresses their needs in a different way. Interviews with parents show that French parents expressed overall higher satisfaction with the care of their babies and were better able to cope with the loss of their child than American parents. Central to the French parents’ perception of autonomy and their sense of satisfaction were the strong doctor–patient relationship, the emphasis on medical certainty in prognosis versus uncertainty in the American context, and the “sentimental work" provided by the team. The American setting, characterized by respect for parental autonomy, did not necessarily translate into full parental involvement in decision-making, and it limited the rapport between doctors and parents to the extent of parental isolation. This empirical comparative approach fosters a much-needed critique of philosophical principles by underscoring, from the parents’ perspective, the lack of “emotional work" involved in the practice of autonomy in the American unit compared to the paternalistic European context. Beyond theoretical and ethical arguments, we must reconsider the practice of autonomy in particularly stressful situations by providing more specific means to cope, translating the impersonal language of “rights" and decision-making into trusting, caring relationships, and sharing the responsibility for making tragic choices.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Anspach, R. Deciding Who Lives: Fateful Choices in the Intensive Care Nursery. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1993.
Beaufils, F. and Bourillon. “L'e´ laboration d'une de´ cision d'ordre e´ thique en re´ animation pe´ diatrique. “Supple´ ment special, “Ethique et re´ animation du nouveau-ne´ et de l'enfant. “Archives Franc¸ aises de Pe´diatrie 43(1986): 571–574.
Beaufils, F., V. Denizart, and M. Meric. “La de´ cision d'arrê t the´ rapeutique en re´ animation ne´ onatale. Rô le des familles et de l'e´ quipe soignante”. Annales me´dicales de Nancy et de l'Est, nume´ ro spe´ cial sur Les de´ cisions d'arrê t the´ rapeutique en re´ animation (adultes et nouveaux ne´ s). Journe´ es d'e´ thique me´ dicale, Abbaye des Pre´ montre´ s, Pont à Mousson 21–22 (juin 1991, 1992): 355–357.
Benfield, D. G., S. A. Leib, and J. H. Vollman. “Grief Response of Parents to Neonatal Death and Parents Participation in Deciding Care. “Pediatrics 62(1978): 71–177.
Bursztajn, H. J., R. I. Feinbloom, R. M. Hamm, A. Brodsky, and H. Putnam. Medical Choices, Medical Chances: How Patients, Families and Physicians Cope with Medical Uncertainty. New York: Delacorte Press/Seymour Laurence, 1981.
Caplan, A. and C. B. Cohen, eds. “Imperiled Newborns. “Hastings Center Review 17 (1987): 5–32.
Cassell, E. J. “Informed Consent in Therapeutic Relationship. ”In Encyclopedia of Bioethics. Edited by W. T. Reich. 767–770. New York: Free Press, 1978.
Charmaz, K. Good Days, Bad Days: The Self in Chronic Illness and Time. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1991.
Cousins, N. Anatomy of an Illness. New York: Norton, 1979.
Cuttini, M., M. Kaminski, R. Sarraci, and U. de Vonderweid. “The EURONIC Project: A European Concerted Action on Information to Parents and Ethical Decision Making in Neonatal Intensive Care. “Pediatric and Perinatal Epidemiology 11 (1997): 461–474.
Cuttini, M., M. Reblagiato, P. Bortoli, G. Hansen, R. de Leeuw, S. Lenoir, J. Persson, M. E. Reid, M. Schroell, U. de Vonderweid, M. Kaminski, H. G. Lenard, M. Orzalesi, and R. Saracci. “Parental Visiting, Communication, and Participation in Ethical Decisions: A Comparison of Neonatal Unit Policies in Europe. “Archives of Diseases in Childhood, Fetal and Neonatal Edition 81(1999): F84–F91.
Cuttini, M., M. Nadai, M. Kaminski, G. Hansen, R. de Leeuw, S. Lenoir, J. Persson, M. Reblagiato, M. E. Reid, U. de Vonderweid, H. G. Lenard, M. Orzalesi, and R. Saracci. “End-of-life Decisions in Neonatal Intensive Care: Physician's Self Reported Practices in Seven European Countries. “Lancet 355(2000): 2112–2118.
Cuttini, M., EURONIC Study Group. “The European Union Collaborative Project on Ethical Decision Making in Neonatal Intensive Care (EURONIC): Findings from 11 Countries. “The Journal of Clinical Ethics 12(2001): 290–296.
Dehan, M. “Introduction'’ In Archives Franc¸ aises de Pe´diatrie 43 supple´ ment spe´ cial “Ethique et re´ animation du nouveau-ne´ et de l'enfant” (1986): 543–544.
Dehan, M. “L'e´ thique et sa Pratique en Ne´ onatologie. ”In Philosophie, e´thique et droit de la me´decine. Edited by D. Folscheid, B. Feuillet-Le Mintier et J. –F. 375–390. Mattei. Paris: PUF, 1997.
De Leeuw, R., M. Cuttini, M. Nadai, I. Berbik, G. Hansen, A. Kucinskas, S. Lenoir, A. Levin, J. Person, M. Rebagliato, M. Reid, M. Scroel, U. de Vonderweid, and other members of the EURONIC group. “Treatment Choices for Extremely Preterm Infants: An International Perspective. “The Journal of Pediatrics 37 (2000): 608–615.
Dubet, F. Sociologie de l'expe´rience. Seuil: Paris, 1994.
Duff, R. S., and A. G. M. Campbell. “Moral and Ethical Dilemmas in the Special Care Nursery. “New England Journal of Medicine 289(1973): 890–894.
Englehardt, H. T. “Ethical Issues in Aiding the Death of Young Children. ”In Beneficient Euthanasia. Edited by M. Kohl. 180–192, New York: Prometheus Books, 1975.
Fedson, A. “Mechanical Reproduction: Neonatal Intensive Care, Medical Ethics, and the Technology Imperative. “Ph. D. diss., University of Chicago, 1999.
Ferrand, E., A. C. Bachoud-Levi, M. Rodrigues, S. Maggiore, C. Brun-Buisson, and F. Lemaire. “Decision Making Capacity and Surrogate Designation in French ICU Patients. “Intensive Care Medicine 27(2001): 1360–1364.
Ferrand, E., R. Robert, P. Ingrand, and F. Lemaire, French LATAREA Group. “Withholding and Withdrawal of Life Support in Intensive-Care Units in France: A Prospective Survey. “French LATAREA Group. Lancet 357(2001): 9–14.
Festinger, L. A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1962.
Fost, N. “Ethics in Pediatric Care. ”In Textbook of Pediatrics, 15th edition, Edited by W. E. Nelson. 12–16. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co., 1996.
Gold, F., M. H. Blond, and C. Herve´. “Pratiques Franc¸ aises Actuelles de L'arrê t The´ rapeutique en Pe´ riode Ne´ onatale. “Annales de Pe´diatrie 43(1996).
Gold, F., and J. Laugier. “La De´ cision d'arrê t The´ rapeutique en Re´ animation Ne´ onatale. Prise en Compte et Prise en Charge Initiale du Handicap. “Archives Franc¸ aises de Pe´diatrie 49(1992): 5–7.
Goold, S. D., B. Williams, and R. M. Arnold. “Conflicts Regarding Decisions to Limit Treatment. “Journal of the American Medical Association 283(2000): 909–914.
Guillemin, J. H., and L. L. Holmstrom. Mixed Blessings: Intensive Care for Newborns. New York: Oxford University Press, 1986.
Hack, M., and G. H. Taylor “Perinatal Injury in Preterm Infants and Later Neurobehavioral Function. “Journal of the American Medical Association 2843(2000): 1939–1947.
Hassenteufel, P. Les me´decins face à l'Etat. Paris: F. N. S. P., 1995.
Heimer, C. A., and L. R. Staffen. For the Sake of Children: The Social Organization of Responsibility in the Hospital and in the Home. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998.
Hughes, E. C. Men and Their Work. Glencoe: Free Press, 1958.
Humes, Edward. Baby ER. New York: Simon and Schuster Trade, 2000.
Jenks, C. “The Postmodern Child. ”In Children in Families: Research and Policy. Edited by J. Brannen and M. O'Brien. 13–25. London: Falmer Press, 1996.
Lantos, J. D., W. L. Meadow, S. H. Miles, E. Ekwo, J. Paton, J. R. Hageman, and M. Siegler. “Providing and Forgoing Resuscitative Therapy for Babies of Very Low Birth Weight. “Journal of Clinical Ethics 3(1992): 283–287.
Lantos, J. D. The Lazarus Case: Life and Death Issues in Neonatal Intensive Care. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, 2001. a]Life Magazine. “Born Too Soon: The High Tech, High Risk Drama of Keeping the Tiniest Babies Alive. “May (2000).
Levin, B. W. “International Perspectives on Treatment Choice in Neonatal Intensive Care Units. “Social Science and Medicine 30, no. 8(1990): 901–912.
Levin, B. W. “The Cultural Context of Decision Making for Catastrophically Ill Newborns: The Case of Baby Jane Doe. ”In Childbirth in America: Anthropological Perspectives. Edited by K. Michaelson. 178–193. South Hadley: Bergind Garvey Publishers Inc., 1988.
Lupton, D., and J. Fenwick. “They've Forgotten the Mum: Constructing and Practicing Motherhood in Special Care Nurseries. “Social Science and Medicine 53 (2001): 1011–1021.
McHaffie, H., I. A. Laing, M. Parker, and J. McMillan. “Deciding for Imperilled Newborns: Medical Authority or Parental Autonomy?” Journal of Clinical Ethics 27 (2001): 33–38.
Meadow, W., T. Reimshisel, and J. D. Lantos. “Birth Weight-Specific Mortality for Extremely Low Birth Weight Infants Vanishes by Four Days of Life: Epidemiology and Ethics in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit. “Pediatrics 97, no. 5(1996): 636–643.
Ness, D. E., and J. Ende. “Denial in the Medical Interview: Recognition and Management. “Journal of the American Medical Association 272(1994): 1777–1781.
Orfali, K. “L'hô pital ou la Critique de la Raison Instrumentale. “The` se de doctorat, EHESS, 1997.
Orfali, K. “The French Paradoxes. ”In The Blackwell Companion to Medical Sociology. Edited by W. Cockerham. 263–286. London: Blackwell, 2000.
Orfali, K. “Etude de cas: Une Comparaison sur l'expe´ rience et le Rô le de la Famille Dans la De´ cision Me´ dicale en Re´ animation Ne´ onatale” aux USA et en France, Rapport MIRE 2001: 225.
Orfali, K. “L'inge´ rence Profane dans la De´ cision Me´ dicale: le Malade, la Famille et l'e´ thique Clinique” Revue franc¸ aise des Affaires socials, 3(2002) 103–124.
Orfali, K. “Parental Role and Medical Decision Making: Fact or Fiction? A Comparative Study of French and American Practices in Neonatal Intensive Care Units. “Social Science and Medicine 58(2004): 2009–2022.
Pinch, W. J., and M. L. Spielman. “Parental Voices in the Sea of Neonatal Ethical Dilemmas. “Issues in Comprehensive Pediatric Nursing 12(1989): 423–435.
Poets, F. C., and B. Sens. “Changes in Intubation Rates and Outcomes of Very Low Birth Weight Infants: A Population Based Study. “Pediatrics 98(1996): 24–27.
Richardson, D. Women, Mothering and Childrearing. Basingstoke, London: Macmillan, 1993.
Saigal, S., B. Stoskopf, D. Feeny, W. Furlong, E. Burrows, P. Rosenbaum, and L. Hoult. “Differences in Preferences for Neonatal Outcomes Among Health Care Professionals, Parents and Adolesecents. “The Journal of the American Medical Association 281(1999): 1991–1997.
Schneider, C. E. The Practice of Autonomy, Patients, Doctors and Medical Decision. New York: Oxford University Press, 1998.
Shaw, J. C. L. “Parenteral Nutrition in the Management of Sick Low Birth Weight Infants. “Pediatric Clinics of North America 20(1973): 333–358.
Shelp, E. E. Born To Die? Deciding the Fate of Critically Ill Newborns. New York: The Free Press, 1985.
Sowards, K. A. “Interfacing Realities: Medical Work in the Intensive Care Nursery”. Paper presented at the American Sociological Organization, 1998.
Sprung, C. L., and L. A. Eidelman. “Worldwide Similarities and Differences in the Forgoing of Life Sustaining Treatments. “Intensive Care Medicine 22(1996): 1003–1005.
Strauss, A., S. Fagerhaugh, B. Suczek, and C. Wiener. The Social Organization of Medical Work. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1985. The Journal Of Clinical Ethics. Special Issue 12 (2001).
Vandvik, I. H., and R. Forde. “Ethical Issues in Parental Decision Making. An Interview Study of Mothers of Children with Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome. “Acta Paediatrica 89(2000): 1129–1133.
Vincent, J. L. “Forgoing Life Support in Western European Intensive Care Units: The Results of an Ethical Questionnaire. “Critical Care Medicine 27(1999): 1626–1633.
Wall, S. N., and J. C. Partridge. “Death in the Intensive CareNursery: Physician Practice of Withdrawing and Withholding Life Support. “Pediatrics 99(1997): 64–70.
Wolpe P. R. “The Triumph of Autonomy in American Bioethics: A Sociological View. ”In Bioethics and Society: Constructing the Ethical Enterprise. Edited by Raymond DeVries and Janardan Subedi. 38–59. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall, 1998.
Zussman, R. Intensive Care. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1997.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Orfali, K., Gordon, E. Autonomy gone awry: a cross-cultural study of parents’ experiences in neonatal intensive care units. Theor Med Bioeth 25, 329–365 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-004-3135-9
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-004-3135-9