Abstract
Here we discuss the challenge posed by self-organization to the Darwinian conception of evolution. As we point out, natural selection can only be the major creative agency in evolution if all or most of the adaptive complexity manifest in living organisms is built up over many generations by the cumulative selection of naturally occurring small, random mutations or variants, i.e., additive, incremental steps over an extended period of time. Biological self-organization—witnessed classically in the folding of a protein, or in the formation of the cell membrane—is a fundamentally different means of generating complexity. We agree that self-organizing systems may be fine-tuned by selection and that self-organization may be therefore considered a complementary mechanism to natural selection as a causal agency in the evolution of life. But we argue that if self-organization proves to be a common mechanism for the generation of adaptive order from the molecular to the organismic level, then this will greatly undermine the Darwinian claim that natural selection is the major creative agency in evolution. We also point out that although complex self-organizing systems are easy to create in the electronic realm of cellular automata, to date translating in silico simulations into real material structures that self-organize into complex forms from local interactions between their constituents has not proved easy. This suggests that self-organizing systems analogous to those utilized by biological systems are at least rare and may indeed represent, as pre-Darwinists believed, a unique ascending hierarchy of natural forms. Such a unique adaptive hierarchy would pose another major challenge to the current Darwinian view of evolution, as it would mean the basic forms of life are necessary features of the order of nature and that the major pathways of evolution are determined by physical law, or more specifically by the self-organizing properties of biomatter, rather than natural selection.
References
Agassiz L (1874) Evolution and the permanence of type. Atlantic Monthly 33:92–101
Anfinsen CB (1973) Principles that govern the folding of protein chains. Science 181:223–230
Bak P (1996) How nature works: the science of self-organized criticality. Springer Verlag, NY
Ball P (1999) The self-made tapestry: pattern formation in nature. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Barth JV, Costantini G, Kern K (2005) Engineering atomic and molecular nanostructures at surfaces. Nature 237:671–679
Bornens M (1991) Cell polarity: intrinsic or externally imposed? New Biol 3:627–636
Brandon C, Tooze J (1999) Introduction to protein structure. Garland Publishing Inc., NY
Brooks RA (2001) The relationship between matter and life. Nature 409:409–411
Camazine S, Deneubourg J-L, Franks NR, Theraulaz G, Bonabeau E (2001) Self-organization in biological systems. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Chambers R (1844) Vestiges of the natural history of creation. John Churchill, London
Chivian D, Robertson T, Bonneau R, Baker D (2003) Ab initio methods. In: Bourne E, Weissig H (eds) Structural informatics. Wiley, NY, pp 547–557
Cherdantseva EM, Cherdantsev VG (2006) Geometry and mechanics of teleost gastrulation and the formation of primary body axes. Int J Dev Biol 50:157–168
Conway Morris S (2003) Life’s solution: inevitable humans in a lonely universe. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Csete ME, Doyle JC (2002) Reverse engineering of biological complexity. Science 295:1164–1669
Darwin C (1872) The origin of species. John Murray, London
Dawkins R (1976) The selfish gene. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Dawkins R (1986) The blind watchmaker, Longman Scientific and Technical, UK
Dawkins R (1996) Climbing mount improbable. W. W. Norton, NY
Dawkins R (2004) The ancestor’s tale. Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London
Deacon T (1997) The symbolic species. Penguin Books, London
Denton MJ, Marshall CJ (2001) The laws of form revisited. Nature 410:417
Denton MJ, Marshall CJ, Legge M (2002) The protein folds as platonic forms: new support for the Pre-Darwinian conception of evolution by natural law. J Theor Biol 219:325–342
Dennett D (1995) Darwin’s dangerous idea. Simon and Schuster, NY
Depew DJ, Weber BH (1988) Consequences of nonequilibrium thermodynamics for the Darwinian tradition. In: Weber BH, Depew DJ, Smith JD (eds) Entropy, information and evolution: new perspectives on physical and biological evolution. MIT press, Cambridge, Mass, pp 316–354
Drexler KE (1986) Engines of creation. Anchor Books, NY
Driesch H (1929) The science and philosophy of the organism. A. and C. Black, London
Edelman GM (1987) Neural Darwinism. Basic Books, NY
Florey J (1969) Statistical mechanics of chain molecules. Wiley, NY
Franks NR, Wilby A, Silverman BW, Tofts C (1992) Self-organizing nest construction in ants: sophisticated building by blind bulldozing. Anim Behav 44:357–375
Gale B (1972) The Darwinian concept of the struggle for existence. ISIS 63:321–344
Gardner R, Surani M, Solter D (2003) Epigenesis versus preformation during mammalian development. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B 358:1313–1315
Gleick J (1998) Chaos. Vintage Press, London
Green JBA, Dominguez I, Davidson LA (2004) Self organization of vertebrate mesoderm based on simple boundary conditions. Dev Dynam 231:576–581
Gribben J (2005) Deep simplicity. Penguin Books, London
Goodwin BC (1994) How the leopard changed its spots. Charles Scribner, NY
Gould SJ (1989) Wonderful life: the Burgess shale and the nature of history. W. W. Norton, NY
Gould SJ (2002) The structure of evolutionary theory. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass
Haken H (1977) Synergetics: an introduction. Nonequilibrium phase transitions and self-organization in physics chemistry and biology. Springer Verlag, NY
Harold FM (2001) The way of the cell. Oxford University Press, NY
Holldobler B, Wilson EO (1990) The ants. Harvard University Press, Mass
Huttner WB, Schmidt AA (2002) Membrane curvature: a case of ‘endofeelin’. Trends Cell Biol 12:155–158
Johnson M (1997) Developmental cognitive neuroscience: an introduction. Blackwell, Oxford
Kalthoff K (1996) Analysis of biological development. McGraw-Hill, NY
Karmiloff-Smith A (1992) Beyond modularity: a developmental perspective on cognitive science. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
Karmiloff-Smith A (2001) Why babies brains are not swiss army knives. In: Rose S, Rose H (eds) Alas Poor Darwin. Vintage, London, pp 144–156
Keller EF (2000) The century of the gene. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass
Keller R, Davidson L, Shook D (2003) How we are shaped: the biomechanics of gastrulation. Differentiation 7:171–205
Kitano H (2002) Systems biology: a brief overview. Science 295:1662–1664
Kirschner M, Gerhard J (1998) Evolvability. PNAS US 95:8420–8427
Kirschner M, Mitchinson T (1986) Beyond self-assembly: from microtubules to morphogenesis. Cell 45:329–342
Kauffman SA (1993) The origins of order. Oxford University Press, NY
Kauffman SA (2000) Investigations. Oxford University Press, NY
Kurzweil R (2005) The singularity is near. Viking, NY
Langton CG (1989) Artificial life. Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, California
Lehn J-M (2002) Towards self-organization and complex matter. Science 295:2400–2403
Levy S (1993) The quest for a new creation. Penguin Books, London
Lewin R (1992) Complexity. Macmillan Press, NY
Lipson N, Pollack JB (2000) Automatic design and manufacture of robotic life forms. Nature 406:974–978
Maynard Smith J, Szathmary E (1999) The origins of life: from the birth of life to the origin of language. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Maynard Smith J (1992) Taking a chance on evolution. New York Rev Books 14:34–36
Mayr E (2001) What evolution is. Basic Books, NY
Miller K (1999) Finding Darwin’s God. Cliff St Books, NY
Misteli T (2001) The concept of self-organization in cellular architecture. J Cell Biol 155:181–185
Mitchinson TJ (1992) Self-organization of polymer–motor systems in the cytoskeleton. Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 336:99–106
Monod J (1972) Chance and necessity. Collins, London
Morowitz HJ (2002) The emergence of everything. Oxford University Press, NY
Motosugi N, Bauer T, Polanski Z, Solter D, Hiiragi T (2005) Polarity of mouse embryo is established at blastocyst and is not prepatterned. Genes Dev 19:1081–1092
Nedelec FJ, Surrey T, Maggs AC, Liebler S (1997) Self-organization of microtubules and motors. Nature 389:305–308
Newman SA (1993) Is segmentation generic? BioEssays 15:277–283
Newman SA (1994) Generic physical mechanisms of tissue morphogenesis: a common basis for development and evolution. J Evol Biol 7:467–488
Newman SA (2002) Developmental mechanisms: putting genes in their place. Bioscience 27:97–104
Nijhout HF (1990) Metaphors and the role of genes in development. Bioessays 12:441–446
Nijhout FH (1999) When developmental pathways diverge. PNAS US 96:5348–5350
Owen R (1849) On the nature of limbs. Jan Van Voorst, London
Owen R (1866) Anatomy of vertebrates. Longmans and Green, London
Popper K (1965) Conjectures and refutations. Harper Row, NY
Przytycka T, Aurora R, Rose GD (1999) A protein taxonomy based on secondary structure. Nat Struct Biol 6:672–682
Ridley M (1997) Evolution. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Ridley M (2004) Nature via Nurture. Harper Perennial, London
Rothemund WK (2006) Folding DNA to create nano shapes and patterns. Nature 440:297–302
Rupke NA (1994) Richard Owen. Yale University Press, New Haven
Ruse M (2003) Darwin and design: does evolution have a purpose? Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass
Russell ES (1916) Form and function. John Murray, London
Salazar-Ciudad I, Newman SA, Sole RV (2001a) Phenotypic and dynamical transitions in model genetic networks I: emergence of patterns and genotype–phenotype relationships. Evol Dev 3:84–94
Salazar-Ciudad I, Sole RV, Newman SA (2001b) Phenotypic and dynamical transitions in model genetic networks II: application to the evolution of segmentation mechanisms. Evol Dev 3:95–103
Salthe SN (1993) Development in evolution:complexity and change in biology. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
Schwann T (1847) Microscopical researches, English translation by Henry Smith, [original published in German in 1839]. Sydenham Society, London
Shatz CJ (1996) Emergence of order in visual system development. PNAS US 93:602–608
Singer SJ, Nicholson GI (1972) The fluid mosaic model of the cell membrane. Science 175:720–731
Soltor D, Knowles BB (1999) Spatial and temporal control of maternal message. In: Russo VEA et al. (eds) Development. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg, pp 389–394
Srinivasan R, Rose GD (2002) Ab Initio prediction of protein structure using LINUS. Proteins Struct Funct Genet 47:489–495
Strogatz SH (1994) Non linear dynamics and chaos. Perseus Books, NY
Surrey T, Nedelec F, Liebler S, Karsenti E (2001) Physical properties determining self-organization of motors and microtubules. Science 292:1167–1171
Trinkaus JP (1984) Cells into organs. Prentice-Hall, NY
von Dassow G, Meir E, Munro EM, Odell GM (2000) The segment polarity network is a robust developmental module. Nature 406:188–192
Van Oudenaarden A, Theriot JA (1999) Symmetry breaking by actin polymerization in a model for cell motility. Nat Cell Biol 1:493–499
Waddington CH (1962) New patterns in genetics and development. Columbia University Press, NY
Weber B.H (1998) Emergence of life and biological selection from the perspective of complex systems dynamics. In: Van de Vijver G, Salthe SN, Delpos M (eds) Evolutionary systems: biological and epistemological perspectives on selection and self-organization. Kluwer, Dordrecth, pp 59–66
Weber BH, Depew DJ (1996) Natural selection and self-organization: dynamical models as a clue to a new evolutionary synthesis. Biol Philos 11:33–65
Webster G, Goodwin BC (1982) The origin of species: a structuralist approach. J Social Struct 5:15–47
Wiley EO, Brooks DR (1982) Victims of history: a non equilibrium approach to evolution. Syst Zool 31:1–24
Weismann A (1902) The evolution theory. Edward Arnold, London
Wicken JS (1986) Entropy and evolution: ground rules for discourse. Syst Zool 35:22–36
Wicken JS (1987) Evolution, thermodynamics and information: extending the Darwinian paradigm. Oxford University Press, NY
Williams G (1966) Adaptation and natural selection. Oxford University Press, NY
Whitesides GM, Grzybowski B (2002) Self-assembly at all scales. Science 295:2418–2421
Wolfram S (2002) A new kind of science. Wolfram Media Inc., Champaign Illinois
Woolfson A (2000) Life without genes. Harper Collins, London
Yates FE, Garfinkel AW, Yates GB (1987) Self-organizing systems: the emergence of order. Plenum Press, NY
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Edelmann, J.B., Denton, M.J. The uniqueness of biological self-organization: challenging the Darwinian paradigm. Biol Philos 22, 579–601 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-006-9055-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-006-9055-5