Abstract
Theories of deliberative democracy have faced the charge of leading to the unjust exclusion of voices from public deliberation. The recent rhetorical turn in deliberative theory aims to respond to this charge. I distinguish between two variants of this response: the supplementing approach and the systemic approach. On the supplementing approach, rhetorical modes of political speech may legitimately supplement the deliberative process, for the sake of those excluded from the latter. On the systemic approach, rhetorical modes of political speech are legitimate within public deliberation, just so long as they result in net benefits to the deliberative system. I argue that neither of these two approaches adequately meets the unjust exclusion charge. Whereas the supplementing approach does not go far enough to incorporate rhetorical speech into public deliberation, the systemic approach goes too far by legitimising forms of rhetoric that risk only exacerbating the problem of unjust exclusion. More constructively, I draw on Aristotle’s conception of rhetoric, as an art (technē) that is a counterpart to dialectic, to argue for a constitutive approach to rhetoric. I show how this approach provides a more expansive notion of deliberation that remains normatively orientated.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abizadeh, A. (2002) The passions of the wise: Phronêsis, rhetoric, and Aristotle’s passionate practical deliberation. The Review of Metaphysics 52(2): 267–296.
Aristotle. (1962) The Politics, trans. T. A. Sinclair. Middlesex: Penguin Books.
Aristotle. (1976) The Nicomachean Ethics, trans. J.A.K. Thomson. London: Penguin Books.
Aristotle. (1991) On Rhetoric: A Theory of Civic Discourse, trans. George A. Kennedy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Aristotle. (2009) Rhetoric, trans. Joe Sachs. Newburyport, MA: Focus Publishing.
Beiner, R. (1983) Political Judgement. London: Methuen.
Bender, J. and Wellbery, D.E. (1990) Rhetoricality: On the Modernist Turn of Rhetoric. In: J. Bender and D. E. Wellbery (eds.) The Ends of Rhetoric: History, Theory, Practice. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Benhabib, S. (1996) Towards a Deliberative Model of Democratic Legitimacy. In: S. Benhabib (ed.) Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Bounds of the Political. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Blaug, R. (1996) New theories of discursive democracy: A user’s guide. Philosophy and Social Criticism 22(1): 49–80.
Bohman, J. (1996) Public Deliberation, Pluralism, Complexity, and Democracy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Bohman, J. (1997) Deliberative Democracy and Effective Social Freedom: Capabilities, Resources, and Opportunities. In: J. Bohman and W. Rehg (eds.) Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Bohman, J. (2012) Representation in the Deliberative System. In: J. Parkinson and J. Mansbridge (eds.) Deliberative Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Booth, R. (2014) US investors set to sell New Era estate in London after protests. The Guardian, 18 December, https://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/dec/18/us-investors-set-sell-new-era-estate-london-protests-westbrook
Brunschwig, J. (1996) Aristotle’s Rhetoric as a “Counterpart” to Dialectic. In: A. O. Rorty (ed.) Essay on Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Cadwalladr, C. (2017) Robert Mercer: the big data billionaire waging war on mainstream media. The Guardian, 26 February, https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/feb/26/robert-mercer-breitbart-war-on-media-steve-bannon-donald-trump-nigel-farage.
Chambers, S. (2009) Rhetoric and the public sphere: Has deliberative democracy abandoned mass democracy? Political Theory 37(3): 323–350.
Charland, M. (1987) Constitutive rhetoric: The case of the Peuple Québécois. The Quarterly Journal of Speech 73(2): 133–150.
Cohen, J. (1997) Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy. In: J. Bohman and W. Rehg (eds.) Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Cooper J.M. (1994) Ethical-political theory in Aristotle’s Rhetoric. In: D. J. Furley and A. Nehmas (eds.) Aristotle’s ‘Rhetoric’: Philosophical Essays. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Devereux & Onians. (2010) Interview with Stewart Lee. Devereux & Onians Productions. 15 January, http://www.atkinsoft.com/stewartlee.html.
Dow, J. (2015) Passions and Persuasion in Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dryzek, J. (2000) Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dryzek, J. (2010) Rhetoric in Democracy: A Systematic Appreciation. Political Theory 38(3): 319–339.
Endberg-Pederesen, T. (1996) Is There an Ethical Dimension to Aristotelian Rhetoric? In: A. O. Rorty (ed.) Essay on Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Farrell, T.B. (1993) The Norms of Rhetorical Culture. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Fontana, B. (2005) Rhetoric and the Roots of Democratic Politics. In: B. Fontana, C. J. Nederman and G. Remer (eds.) Talking Democracy: Historical Perspectives on Rhetoric and Democracy. Pennsylvania: The Pennsylvania State University Press.
Fox10. (2017) ‘New White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci Speaks After Sean Spicer Resigns’. 21 July, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fz-VaIjXorQ.
Frank, J. (2009) Staging the Dissensus: Frederick Douglass and ‘We, the People’. In: A Schaap (ed.) Law and Agonistic Politics. London: Ashgate.
Fung, A. (2005) Deliberation before the revolution: Towards an ethics of deliberative democracy in an unjust world. Political Theory 33(3): 397–419.
Garsten, B. (2006) Saving Persuasion: A Defence of Rhetoric and Judgement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Garver, E. (1994) Aristotle’s Rhetoric: An Art of Character. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gorgias. (1991) Encomium of Helen. In: G. A. Kennedy (ed.) On Rhetoric: A Theory of Civic Discourse, trans. George A. Kennedy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Guttmann, A. and Thompson, D. (1996) Democracy and Disagreement. Harvard: Harvard University Press.
Guttmann, A. and Thomson, D. (2004) Why Deliberative Democracy? Princeton: Princeton University Press 2004.
Habermas, J. (1997) Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy, trans. W. Rehg. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Haliwell, S. (1996) The Challenge of Rhetoric to Political and Ethical Theory in Aristotle. In: A. O. Rorty (ed.) Essay on Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Hauser, G.A. (1995) Between philosophy and rhetoric: Interpositions within traditions. Philosophy and Rhetoric 28(3): iii–xvii.
Irwin, T.H. (1996) Ethics in the Rhetoric and in the Ethics. In: A. O. Rorty (ed.) Essay on Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kant, I. (1953) The Critique of Judgement, trans. J. C. Meredith. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Knight, J. and Johnson, J. (1997) What Sort of Equality Does Deliberative Democracy Require? In J. Bohman and W. Rehg (eds.) Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Krause, S.H. (2008) Civil Passions: Moral Sentiment and Democratic Deliberation. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Manin, B. (1987) On legitimacy and political deliberation. Political Theory 15(3): 338–368.
Mansbridge, J., Bohman, J., Chambers, C., Christano, T., Fung, A., Parkinson, J., Thompson, D.F., Warren, M. E. (2012) A Systemic Approach to Deliberative Democracy. In: J. Parkinson and J. Mansbridge (eds.) Deliberative Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
McCabe, M.M. (1994) Aristotle’s Defence of Rhetoric. In: D. J. Furley and A. Nehmas (eds.) Aristotle’s ‘Rhetoric’: Philosophical Essays. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Meyer, M. (1994) Rhetoric, Language, and Reason. Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania University Press.
Norval, A.J. (2007) Aversive Democracy: Inheritance and Originality in the Democratic Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nussbaum, M.C. (1990) Love’s Knowledge: Essays on Philosophy and Literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Owen, D. and Smith, S. (2015) Survey article: Deliberation, democracy, and the systemic turn. The Journal of Political Philosophy 23(2): 213–234
Perelman, C. (1982) The Realm of Rhetoric, trans. W. Kluback. Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press.
Reeve, C.D.C. (1996) Philosophy, Politics, and Rhetoric in Aristotle. In: A. O. Rorty (ed.) Essays on Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Remer, G. (1999) Two models of deliberation: Oratory and conversation in ratifying the constitution. The Journal of Political Philosophy 8(1): 68–90.
Ricoeur, P. (2003) The Rule of Metaphor: The Creation of Meaning in Language, trans. R. Czerny, K. McLaughlin and J. Costello. London: Routledge.
Rostbøll, C.F. (2008) Deliberative Freedom: Deliberative Democracy as Critical Theory. Albany: Suny Press.
Sachs, J. (2009) Introduction. In: J. Sachs (ed.) Plato Gorgias and Aristotle Rhetoric. Newburyport, MA: Focus Publishing.
Sanders, L. (1997) Against Deliberation. Political Theory 25(3): 347–376.
Schiappa, E. (2001) Second thoughts on the critique of big rhetoric. Philosophy and Rhetoric 34(3): 260–274.
Schütrumpf, E. (1994) Some Observations on the Introduction to Aristotle’s Rhetoric. In: D. J. Furley and A. Nehmas (eds.) Aristotle’s “Rhetoric”: Philosophical Essays. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Sprute, J. (1994) Aristotle and the Legitimacy of Rhetoric. In: D. J. Furley and A. Nehmas (eds.) Aristotle’s “Rhetoric”: Philosophical Essays. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Tully, J. (2002) The unfreedom of the moderns in comparison to their ideals of constitutional democracy. The Modern Law Review 65 (2): 204–228
Tyler, I. (2013) Revolting Subjects: Social Abjection and Resistance in Neoliberal Britain. London: Zed Books.
Wardy, R. (1996) Mighty Is the Truth and It Shall Prevail In: A. O. Rorty (ed.) Essay on Aristotle’s Rhetoric. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Welsh, S. (2002) Deliberative Democracy and the Rhetorical Production of Political Culture. Rhetoric and Public Affairs 5(4): 679–707.
Welsh, S. (2013) The Rhetorical Surface of Democracy. Plymouth: Lexington Books.
Wintour, P. and Collier, H. (2014) Nigel Farage launches Ukip campaign amid criticism of ‘racist’ rhetoric. The Guardian, 22 April, http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/apr/22/nigel-farage-ukip-european-elections-campaign
Yack, B. (2003) Rhetoric and public reasoning: An aristotelian understanding of public deliberation. Political Theory 34(4): 417–438.
Young, I.M. (1996) Communication and the Other: Beyond Deliberative Democracy. In S. Benhabib (ed.) Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Bounds of the Political. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Young, I.M. (2000) Inclusion and Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Young, I.M. (2001) Activist challenges to deliberative democracy. Political Theory 29(5): 670–690.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank Fabian Freyenhagen, David McNeill, Alexandra Popescu, and two anonymous reviewers for helpful discussions and feedback. Special thanks to Dan Watts.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gormley, S. Deliberation, unjust exclusion, and the rhetorical turn. Contemp Polit Theory 18, 202–226 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41296-018-0254-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41296-018-0254-z