Abstract
Cities around the world have increasingly turned to iconic architectural development (IAD) to compete for tourists, investment and skilled migrants. However, IADs represent more than just an economic development tool, they are explicit attempts to create iconic representations of place. As such IADs provide an important opportunity to better understand how objects gain “iconic power”—defined as the fusion of powerful social meanings with the aesthetic surface of physical objects. Through a comparative study of two museum expansion projects, this article investigates how the production process influences the content and intensity of the meanings attributed to the buildings. Adopting a cultural pragmatics approach, I demonstrate that IADs constitute a social performance where the actions taken by developers to design, construct, and promote their buildings are interpreted by the outside public and inform the meanings attributed to the final buildings. In identifying the relationship between production and performance, this article extends our understanding of iconic power while also demonstrating how theories from the “Strong Program” in cultural sociology can be exported to advance the study of cities and urban development.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Nonetheless, elite architects, like artists, are promoted as singular geniuses, mystified by the “charismatic ideology of creation” (Bourdieu 1996).
In his influential “regime theory,” Stone (1989) distinguishes the power to act, characteristic of the urban political arena, from the State’s power to command. In other words, elites in the urban political arena are distinguished by their ability to get things done (e.g., build a skyscraper, influence the route of a highway, etc.), rather than their ability to command a subject population.
It should be noted that the museums had the means of symbolic production only to begin an expansion process by hiring an architect, holding fundraisers, and other initial steps. In order to build their actual expansions, they would need to ensure that their expansion plans appealed to certain influential audiences—most notably the governments of Ontario and Canada, which had existing funding programs with various sets of conditions, criteria, and mission statements. See Jenkins (2005) and Patterson (2012) for a more expansive analysis on the various government agendas that serve as a backdrop for the ROM and AGO expansions.
All financial figures in this paper are quoted in Canadian dollars.
The neighborhoods that surround the ROM have a history of politically active residents’ associations. The famous urban thinker and activist Jane Jacobs lived a few blocks from the ROM until her death in 2006 and many residents believed they were continuing her legacy of urban activism.
The ROM’s renaissance “script” is an example of what Joo (2016, p. 24) calls a “romantic narrative of urban progress.” Such narratives were already emerging in Toronto due to the opening of the heritage “Distillery District” in 2003 (ibid).
I cannot independently confirm the statements that this participant attributes to William Thorsell and Daniel Libeskind. The significance of this quote is the sentiment it expresses, which was widely shared in the community and the press.
It is also worth noting how the critics attribute the architecture primarily to the individual visions and personalities of the two architects, mostly ignoring the influences of the larger social context examined within this paper.
From the perspective of consumption, as opposed to production, Bartmanski and Woodward (2015) have made a similar argument with regard to vinyl records. The material qualities of records create certain “affordances” for how they can be consumed. However, they remain mundane, mass produced commodities until they are incorporated into a public performance (by a DJ) that transforms them into an icon of authenticity and charisma in music.
References
Adams, James. 2001. Ideas abound for ROM plans. Globe and Mail, A18.
Adams, James. 2004. Is Gehry getting a ‘bad rap’? Globe and Mail, R1.
Adams, James. 2005. ROM condo would tower over U of T. Globe and Mail, A1.
Adams, James, and Sarah Milroy. 2004. Tanenbaum disputes AGO costs. Globe and Mail, A13.
“AGO must rebuild trust” [Editorial]. 2004. Toronto Star, A18.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. 2004a. From the depths of despair: Performance, counterperformance, and ‘September 11’. Sociological Theory 22 (1): 88–105.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. 2004b. Cultural pragmatics: Social performance between ritual and strategy. Sociological Theory 22 (4): 527–573.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. 2006. The Civil Sphere. New York: Oxford University Press.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. 2008. Iconic consciousness: The material feeling of meaning. Environment and Planning D 26 (5): 782–794.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. 2010. The performance of politics: Obama’s victory and the democratic struggle for power. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Alexander, Jeffrey C. 2012. Iconic power and performance: The role of the critic. In Iconic power: Materiality and meaning in social life, ed. Jeffrey C. Alexander, Dominik Bartmanski, and Bernhard Giesen, 25–35. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan.
Barber, John. 2004, January 29. “Wild Gehry has planned a Volvo of a building for Toronto.” Globe and Mail, A10.
Bartmanski, Dominik. 2011. Successful icons of failed time: Rethinking post-communist nostalgia. Acta Sociologica 54 (3): 213–231.
Bartmanski, Dominik. 2012. How to become an iconic social thinker: The intellectual pursuits of Malinowski and Foucault. European Journal of Social Theory 15 (4): 427–453.
Bartmanski, Dominik. 2017. A temple of social hope? Tempelhof airport in Berlin and its transformation. In National matters, ed. Geneviève Zubrzycki, 216–240. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Bartmanski, Dominik, and Jeffrey C. Alexander. 2012. Materiality and meaning in social life: Toward an iconic turn in cultural sociology. In Iconic power: Materiality and meaning in social life, 1–12. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan.
Bartmanski, Dominik, and Ian Woodward. 2015. The vinyl: The analogue medium in the age of digital reproduction. Journal of Consumer Culture 15 (1): 3–27.
Becker, Howard. 1982. Art worlds. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984. Distinction. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1996. The rules of art. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Boxer, Sarah. 1998. Critic’s notebook; The photos that changed Pollock’s life. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/1998/12/15/arts/critic-s-notebook-the-photos-that-changed-pollock-s-life.html. Accessed 1 Feb 2018.
Boyle, Theresa. 2006. ROM exec heightens expectations. Toronto Star, P9.
Burgen, Stephen. 2014. Frank Gehry gives journalist the finger. The Guardian. http://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2014/oct/24/frank-gehry-journalist-finger-architecture-shit. Accessed 3 Apr 2016.
Cowan, James. 2005. ROM with a view flayed as ‘ugly.’ National Post, A15.
Davey, Peter. 2007. Debunking theoryspeak. Architectural Journal.
de la Fuente, Eduardo. 2013. Why aesthetics patterns matter: Art and a ‘qualitative’ social theory. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 44 (2): 168–185.
Douglas, Gordon C.C. 2012. Cultural expectations and urban development: The role of ‘cultural sensitivity’ and ‘cultural sincerity’ in local growth politics. Sociological Perspectives 55 (1): 213–236.
Durkheim, Emile. [1912] 1995. The elementary forms of religious life. New York, NY: Free Press.
Essary, Elizabeth Helen, and Christian Ferney. 2013. Pomp and power, performers and politicians: The California theatre state. American Journal of Cultural Sociology 1 (1): 96–124.
Evans, Graeme. 2003. Hard-branding the cultural city—from Prado to Prada. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 27 (2): 417–440.
Florida, Richard. 2002. The rise of the creative class. New York: Basic Books.
Friedland, Roger, and Robert R. Alford. 1991. Bringing society back in: Symbols, practices, and institutional contradictions. In The new institutionalism in organizational analysis, ed. Walter W. Powell and Paul J. DiMaggio, 232–266. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Harvey, David. 1989. From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation in urban governance in late capitalism. Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography 71 (1): 3–17.
Harvey, David. 2005. A brief history of neoliberalism. New York: Oxford University Press.
Ho, K.C. 2006. Where do community iconic structures fit in a globalizing city? City 10 (1): 91–100.
Hume, Christopher. 2001. City on edge of renaissance. Toronto Star, B01.
Gieryn, Thomas. 2002. What buildings do. Theory and Society 31 (1): 35–74.
Griswold, Wendy, and Muhammed Bhadmus. 2013. The Kano Durbar: Political aesthetics in the bowel of the elephant. American Journal of Cultural Sociology 1 (1): 125–151.
Gyourko, Joseph, Christopher Mayer, and Todd Sinai. 2006. “Superstar cities.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series. Online. http://www.nber.org/papers/w12355.pdf. Accessed 30 Mar 2012.
Jenkins, Barbara. 2005. Toronto’s cultural renaissance. Canadian Journal of Communication 30 (2): 169–186.
Joo, Jin Su. 2016. The cultural logic of heritage redevelopment mega-projects. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Yale University, New Haven.
Jones, Paul R. 2006. The sociology of architecture and the politics of building: The discursive construction of ground zero. Sociology 40 (3): 549–565.
Kaika, Maria, and Korinna Thielen. 2006. Form follows power: A genealogy of urban shrines. City 10 (1): 59–69.
Kennicott, Philip. 2008. A complex legacy. Washington Post. M01.
Kuitenbrouwer, Peter. 2006. ROM makes it clear: ‘Crystal’ more like siding: Not transparent. National Post, A12.
Kunstler, James Howard. 1993. The geography of nowhere. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster Inc.
Larsen, Håkon. 2016. Performing legitimacy. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Larson, Magali Sarfatti. 1993. Behind the postmodern facade. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Larson, Magali Sarfatti. 1994. Architectural competitions as discursive events. Theory and Society 23 (4): 469–504.
Liebenberg, Matthew. 2008. ROM Crystal one of the seven new wonders of architecture world, magazine says. National Post.
Luscombe, Belinda. 2001. ROM with a view. Time (Canadian Edition) 158 (26): 62.
Mast, Jason. 2006. The cultural pragmatics of event-ness: The Clinton/Lewinsky Affair. In Social performance: Symbolic action, cultural pragmatics, and ritual, ed. J. Alexander, B. Giesen, and J. Mast, 115–145. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mast, Jason. 2012. The performative presidency. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mays, John Bentley. 2007. Crystal gazing, 96–105. Azure Magazine.
McDonnell, Terence E. 2016. Best laid plans. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
McDowell, Adam. 2007. What will visitors to the new Art Gallery of Ontario see next year? National Post. AL10.
McGovern, Stephen J. 2009. Mobilization on the waterfront: The ideological/cultural roots of potential regime change in Philadelphia. Urban Affairs Review 44 (5): 663–694.
McNeill, Donald. 2009. The global architect. New York, NY: Routledge.
Miles, Steven, and Ronan Paddison. 2005. The rise and rise of culture-led urban regeneration. Urban Studies 42 (5): 833–839.
Milroy, Sarah. 2003. “Gallery in the throes of a gamble; The troubled AGO might look to the ROM for a cautionary tale.” Globe and Mail, R15.
Mollenkopf, John. 1983. The contested city. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Molotch, Harvey. 1976. The city as a growth machine: Toward a political economy of place. American Journal of Sociology 82 (2): 309–332.
Molotch, Harvey. 2002. Place in product. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 26 (4): 665–688.
Mossberger, Karen, and Gerry Stoker. 2001. The evolution of urban regime theory: The challenge of conceptualization. Urban Affairs Review 36 (6): 810–835.
“Museum as artefact” [Editorial]. 2007, May 26. Toronto Star, B01.
Nuttall-Smith, Chris. 2008. The curse of the aluminum crystal. Toronto Life 42 (9): 54–66.
Ouroussoff, Nicolai. 2008, November 14. “Gehry puts a very different signature on his old hometown’s museum.” New York Times. C1.
Patterson, Matt. 2012. The role of the public institution in iconic architectural development. Urban Studies 49 (15): 3289–3305.
Plaza, Beatriz. 2006. The return on investment of the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 30 (2): 452–467.
Pogliano, Andrea. 2015. Iconic photographs in the newsroom. An ethnography of visual news-making in Italy and France. Sociologica 9 (1): 1–52.
Ponzini, Davide, and Michele Nastasi. 2011. Starchitecture. Turin: Allemandi.
Posner, Michael. 2001. Architect Gehry in talks to build expanded AGO. Globe and Mail, A1.
Reed, Isaac Ariail. 2013. Charismatic performance: A study of Bacon’s Rebellion. American Journal of Cultural Sociology 1 (2): 254–287.
Ritzer, George. 1993. The McDonaldization of society. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
Rochon, Lisa. 2004. Is Gehry in the building? Globe and Mail, R1.
Rochon, Lisa. 2007. Crystal scatters no light. Globe and Mail, R1.
Rochon, Lisa. 2007. Cityspace: 2007 year in review architecture. Globe and Mail, R7.
Rochon, Lisa. 2008. A monumental moment. Globe and Mail, R1.
Royal Ontario Museum. 2003. Groundbreaking event signals start of Renaissance ROM construction [Press release].
Royal Ontario Museum. 2008. Michael Lee-Chin Crystal facts [Press release].
Sassen, Saskia. 2005. The global city: Introducing a concept. Brown Journal of World Affairs 11 (2): 27–43.
Simmel, Georg. [1903] 1950. The metropolis and mental life. In Kurt H. Wolf (ed.) The sociology of Georg Simmel, 409–424. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
Sklair, Leslie. 2005. The transnational capitalist class and contemporary architecture in globalizing cities. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 29 (3): 485–500.
Sklair, Leslie. 2010. Iconic architecture and the culture-ideology of consumerism. Theory, Culture & Society 27 (5): 135–159.
Smith, Philip. 2012. Becoming iconic: The cases of Woodstock and Bayreuth. In Iconic power: Materiality and meaning in social life, ed. Jeffrey C. Alexander, Dominik Bartmanski, and Bernhard Giesen, 171–183. New York: Palgrave MacMillan.
Solaroli, Marco. 2015. Iconicity: A category for social and cultural theory. Sociologica 9 (1): 1–52.
Stevens, Garry. 2002. The favored circle: The social foundations of architectural distinction. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Stone, Clarence N. 1989. Regime politics: Governing Atlanta, 1946–1988. Lawrence: University of Kansas Press.
Swidler, Ann. 1986. Culture in action: Symbols and strategies. American Sociological Review 51 (2): 273–286.
Thorsell, William. 2004. The medium is the message; Forget the economic benefits, great architecture must stand on its own merits. Globe and Mail, A13.
Wagner-Pacifici, Robin, and Barry Schwartz. 1991. The Vietnam Veterans Memorial: Commemorating a difficult past. American Journal of Sociology 97 (2): 376–420.
Weber, Max. 1946. From Max Weber: Essays in sociology. H. H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills (eds.). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Witkin, Robert W. 1974. The intelligence of feeling. London: Heinemann Educational Books.
Zuckerman, Ezra W. 1999. The categorical imperative: Securities analysts and the illegitimacy discount. American Journal of Sociology 104 (5): 1398–1438.
Zukin, Sharon. 2010. Naked city: The death and life of authentic urban places. New York: Oxford University Press.
Zukin, Sharon, Robert Baskerville, Miriam Greenberg, Courtney Guthreau, Jean Halley, and Mark Halling. 1998. From Coney Island to Las Vegas in the rrban imaginary: Discursive practices of growth and decline. Urban Affairs Review 33 (5): 627–654.
Acknowledgements
This article benefited from the comments and suggestions of several people. I would like to thank John Hannigan, Judith Taylor, Daniel Silver, Leonard Nevarez, Vanina Leschziner, Phillipa Chong, the anonymous AJCS reviews, and Jeffrey Alexander for their guidance and advice. I would also like to thank all those who participated in my research for sharing their perspectives and experiences.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Patterson, M. Architecture as performance art: evaluating “iconic power” in the development of two museums. Am J Cult Sociol 8, 158–190 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41290-018-00067-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41290-018-00067-2