Abstract
Weed management strategies likely provide trade-offs in economic implications. Farmers may prioritize weed control during the “critical period” of the crop and ignore subsequent weeds; they may focus on the long term by eliminating additions to the weed seedbank with a “zero seed rain” approach; or they may suppress weed emergence with polyethylene (PE) or hay mulch. We aimed to compare the economic trade-offs of these approaches by implementing each system in a test crop of yellow onion (Allium cepa L.). We found that the zero seed rain system required the most weeding labor and the most evenly spread workload, while the hay mulch system required the most concentrated workload, due to the task of mulching. Despite the labor costs of the zero seed rain and hay mulch systems, net farm income (NFI) was most sensitive to onion yield and these systems resulted in the greatest NFI. The hay mulch system represented the least economic risk, followed by the zero seed rain, PE mulch, and critical period systems, respectively. In a subsequent crop of sweet corn, NFI was decreased 2524 USD ha−1 in plots where the critical period system had been implemented the previous year, likely due to increased weed competition. Overall, despite the long-term focus of the zero seed rain and hay mulch systems related to the weed seedbank and soil quality, respectively, these systems were most profitable in this short-term study.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bagavathiannan MV, Norsworthy JK (2012) Late-season seed production in arable weed communities: management implications. Weed Sci 60(03):325–334. https://doi.org/10.1614/WS-D-11-00222.1
Baker BP, Mohler CL (2014) Weed management by upstate New York organic farmers: strategies, techniques and research priorities. Renew Agr Food Syst 30:1–10
Bond W, Burston S (1996) Timing the removal of weeds from drilled salad onions to prevent crop losses. Crop Prot 15(2):205–211. https://doi.org/10.1016/0261-2194(95)00127-1
Bond W, Burston S, Moore HC (1998) Changes in the weed seedbank following different weed control treatments in transplanted bulb onions grown organically and conventionally. Asp Appl Biol 51:273–296
Brault D, Stewart KA, Jenni S (2002) Growth, development, and yield of head lettuce cultivated on paper and polyethylene mulch. Hortscience 37:92–94
Brown B, Gallandt ER (2017a) A systems comparison of contrasting organic weed management strategies. Weed Sci 66(01):109–120. https://doi.org/10.1017/wsc.2017.34
Brown B, Gallandt ER (2017b) To each their own: case studies of four successful, small-scale organic vegetable farmers with distinct weed management strategies. Renew Agr Food Syst:1–7. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1742170517000576
Caldwell B, Mohler CL, Ketterings QM, DiTommaso A (2014) Yields and profitability during and after transition in organic grain cropping systems. Agron J 106(3):871–880. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj13.0286
Chan S, Caldwell BA, Rickard BJ, Mohler CL (2011) Economic performance of organic cropping systems for vegetables in the Northeast. J Agribusiness 29:59–81
Cirujeda A, Aibar J, Anzalone A, Martín-Closas L, Meco R, Moreno MM, Pardo A, Pelacho AM, Rojo F, Royo-Esnal A, Suso AM, Zaragoza C (2012) Biodegradable mulch instead of polyethylene for weed control of processing tomato production. Agron Sustain Dev 32(4):889–897. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13593-012-0084-y
Cox WJ, Singer JS, Shields EJ, Waldron JK, Bergstrom GC (1999) Agronomics and economics of different weed management systems in corn and soybean. Agron J 91(4):585–591. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj1999.914585x
Davis AS, Hill JD, Chase CA, Johanns AM, Liebman M (2012) Increasing cropping system diversity balances productivity, profitability and environmental health. PLoS One 7(10):e47149. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0047149
DeDecker JJ, Masiunas JB, Davis AS, Flint CG (2014) Weed management practice selection among Midwest U.S. organic growers. Weed Sci 62(03):520–531. https://doi.org/10.1614/WS-D-13-00138.1
Farias-Larios J, Orozco-Santos M (1997) Effect of polyethylene mulch colour on aphid populations, soil temperature, fruit quality, and yield of watermelon under tropical conditions. New Zeal J Crop Hort 25(4):369–374. https://doi.org/10.1080/01140671.1997.9514028
Gallandt ER (2014) Weed management in organic farming. In: Chauhan BS, Mahajan G (eds) Recent advances in weed management. Springer, New York, pp 63–86
Gifford EM, Stewart KD (1965) Ultrastructure of vegetative and reproductive apices of Chenopodium album. Science 149(3679):75–77. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.149.3679.75
Halloran JM, Griffin TS, Honeycutt CW (2005) An economic analysis of potential rotation crops for Maine potato cropping systems. Am J Potato Res 82(2):155–162. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02853653
Hardaker JB, Huirne RBM, Anderson JR, Lien G (2004) Coping with risk in agriculture. CAB International Publishing, Oxfordshire. https://doi.org/10.1079/9780851998312.0000
Hewson RT, Roberts HA (1971) The effects of weed removal at different times on the yield of bulb onions. J Hort Sci 46:471–483
Jabbour R, Gallandt ER, Zwickle S, Wilson RS, Doohan D (2014) Organic farmer knowledge and perceptions are associated with on-farm weed seedbank densities in Northern New England. Weed Sci 62(02):338–349. https://doi.org/10.1614/WS-D-13-00098.1
Kaya C, Higgs D, Kirnak H (2005) Influence of polyethylene mulch, irrigation regime, and potassium rates on field cucumber yield and related traits. J Plant Nut 28(10):1739–1753. https://doi.org/10.1080/01904160500250797
Knezevic SZ, Evans SP, Blankenship EE, Van Acker RC, Lindquist JL (2002) Critical period for weed control: the concept and data analysis. Weed Sci 50(6):773–786. https://doi.org/10.1614/0043-1745(2002)050[0773:CPFWCT]2.0.CO;2
Kolb LN, Gallandt ER, Molloy T (2010) Improving weed management in organic spring barley: physical weed control vs. interspecific competition. Weed Res 50(6):597–605. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3180.2010.00818.x
Kolb LN, Gallandt ER, Mallory EB (2012) Impact of spring wheat planting density, row spacing, and mechanical weed control on yield, grain protein, and economic return in Maine. Weed Sci 60(02):244–253. https://doi.org/10.1614/WS-D-11-00118.1
Kruskal WH, Wallis WA (1952) Use of ranks in one-criterion variance analysis. J Am Stat Assoc 47(260):583–621. https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.1952.10483441
Law DM, Rowell AB, Snyder JC, Williams MA (2006) Weed control efficacy of organic mulches in two organically managed bell pepper production systems. HortTechnology 16:225–232
Lazarus WF (2015) Machinery cost estimates. University of Minnesota Extension
Lu Y-C, Watkins B, Teasdale J (1999) Economic analysis of sustainable agricultural cropping systems for Mid-Atlantic states. J Sustain Agric 15(2-3):77–93. https://doi.org/10.1300/J064v15n02_09
McErlich AF, Boydston RA (2013) Current state of weed management in organic and conventional cropping systems. In: Young SL, Pierce FJ (eds) Automation: the future of weed control in cropping systems. Springer Science+Business Media, Dordrecht, pp 11–32
Menges RM, Tamez S (1981) Common sunflower (Helianthus annuus L) interference in onions. Weed Sci 29:641–647
Nieto HJ, Brondo MA, Gonzales JT (1968) Critical periods of the crop growth cycle for competition from weeds. PANS (C) 14:159–166
NOAA (2016) Land-based station data. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/land-based-station-data. Accessed 17 August, 2016
Nordell A, Nordell E (2009) Weed the soil, not the crop. Acres USA 40:21–28
Norris R (1999) Ecological implications of using thresholds for weed management. J Crop Prod 2(1):31–58. https://doi.org/10.1300/J144v02n01_03
Ott SL, Hargrove WL (1989) Profits and risks of using crimson clover and hairy vetch cover crops in no-till corn production. Am J Altern Agric 4(02):65–70. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0889189300002745
Özkan Ş, Farquharson RJ, Hill J, Malcolm B (2015) A stochastic analysis of the impact of input parameters on profit of Australian pasture-based dairy farms under variable carbon price scenarios. Environ Sci Pol 48:163–171. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2014.12.012
Pielou EC (1975) Ecological diversity. John Wiley and Sons, New York
Roberts HA, Feast PM (1972) Fate of seeds of some annual weeds in different depths of cultivated and undisturbed soil. Weed Res 12(4):316–324. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-3180.1972.tb01226.x
Sanders DC, Cure JD, Schultheis JR (1999) Yield response of watermelon to planting density, planting pattern, and polyethylene mulch. Hortscience 34:1221–1223
Schonbeck MW (1998) Weed suppression and labor costs associated with organic, plastic, and paper mulches in small-scale vegetable production. J Sustain Agr 13:13–33
Schonbeck MW, Evanylo GK (1998a) Effects of mulches on soil properties and tomato production I. Soil temperature, soil moisture and marketable yield. J Sustain Agr 13(1):55–81. https://doi.org/10.1300/J064v13n01_06
Schonbeck MW, Evanylo GK (1998b) Effects of mulches on soil properties and tomato production II. Plant-available nitrogen, organic matter input, and tilth-related properties. J Sustain Agr 13(1):83–100. https://doi.org/10.1300/J064v13n01_07
Trdan S, Žnidarčič D, Kač M, Vidrih M (2008) Yield of early white cabbage grown under mulch and non-mulch conditions with low populations of onion thrips (Thrips tabaci Lindeman). Int J Pest Manage 54(4):309–318. https://doi.org/10.1080/09670870802220596
USDA NASS (2014) 2014 Organic Survey. U.S. Department of Agriculture, National Agricultural Statistics Service. https://www.agcensus.usda.gov/Publications/2012/Online_Resources/Organics/. Accessed 15 June 2016
Vavrina CS, Roka FM (2000) Comparison of plastic mulch and bare-ground production economics for short-day onions in a semitropical environment. HortTechnology 10:326–330
Ware GW, McCollum JP (1975) Onions: producing vegetable crops. The Interstate Printers & Publishers Inc., Danville, IL, pp 359–377
Weaver SE, McWilliams EL (1980) The biology of Canadian weeds. 44. Amaranthus retroflexus L., A. powellii S., Wats. and A. hybridus L. Can J Plant Sci 60(4):1215–1234. https://doi.org/10.4141/cjps80-175
Wicks GA, Johnston DN, Nuland DS, Kinbacher EJ (1973) Competition between annual weeds and sweet Spanish onions. Weed Sci 21:436–439
Wilcoxon F (1945) Individual comparisons by ranking methods. Biom Bull 1(6):80–83. https://doi.org/10.2307/3001968
Zhang TQ, Tan CS, Warner J (2007) Fresh market sweet corn production with clear and wavelength selective soil mulch films. Can J Plant Sci 87(3):559–564. https://doi.org/10.4141/P06-103
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to farm manger Joseph Cannon; our field technicians Thomas Macy, Anthony Codega, and Isaac Mazzeo; and interns Lydia Fox, Diego Grossman, and Lucia Helder.
Funding
Funding for the work reported here was provided by a Graduate Student Grant from the United States Department of Agriculture, Northeast Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education Program, entitled Balancing economy and ecology: A systems comparison of leading organic weed management strategies, project GNE14-072-27806, This project was supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Hatch project number ME021606 through the Maine Agricultural & Forest Experiment Station. Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station Publication Number 3582.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic supplementary material
Online resource 1
(DOCX 16 kb)
Online resource 2
(DOCX 42 kb)
Online resource 3
(DOCX 34 kb)
Online resource 4
(DOCX 56 kb)
Online resource 5
(DOCX 58 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brown, B., Hoshide, A.K. & Gallandt, E.R. An economic comparison of weed management systems used in small-scale organic vegetable production. Org. Agr. 9, 53–63 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13165-018-0206-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13165-018-0206-1