Abstract
The paradigm of service orientation and its incarnation in the form of service-oriented architecture (SOA) and information technology (IT) services play a crucial role in enabling companies to achieve considerable competitive advantages. However, to be able to leverage the opportunities of SOA and IT services, companies need to gain a thorough understanding of the business value of IT service investments. Nevertheless, research on IT services has focused mainly on technical questions so far; the economic perspective largely has been neglected. Therefore, the authors aim to contribute to the ex ante valuation of IT service investments from a decision theoretical point of view. Using decision theory as a theoretical base, the main aim is to identify and discuss specific challenges regarding the financial ex ante valuation of IT service investments, which arise from the inherent flexibility of IT services and the various interdependencies within a company’s IT service portfolio. The authors thereby emphasize that the application of common methods from financial theory for valuating IT service investments has to be treated with caution, as these methods are often tied to rather restrictive assumptions based on the specifics of capital markets. By analyzing different clusters of IT service investment decision problems using decision theory, the authors identify and discuss pitfalls that might occur when applying financial valuation methods to capture the flexibility and interdependencies of IT service investments. The decision theoretical considerations are intended to help build a solid basis for future multi-criteria valuation approaches, of which an essential component is a theoretically well-founded financial valuation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abelein U, Habryn F, Becker A (2009) Towards a holistic framework for describing and evaluating business benefits of a service oriented architecture (SOA). In: Proceedings of the 13th enterprise distributed object computing conference, Auckland
Alshawi S, Irani Z, Baldwin LP (2003) Benchmarking information technology investment and benefits extraction. Benchmarking 10(4):414–423
Angell IO, Smithson S (1991) Appraisal, monitoring and control. information systems management: opportunities and risks. MacMillan, Basingstoke, pp 189–212
Aral S, Weill P (2007) IT assets, organizational capabilities, and firm performance: how resource allocations and organizational differences explain performance variation. Organ Sci 18(5):763–780
Arrow KJ (1965) Aspects of the theory of risk bearing. Yrjö Jahnsson lectures, Helsinki
Asundi J, Kazman R (2001) A foundation for the economic analysis of software architectures. In: Proceedings of the 3rd workshop on economics-driven software engineering research, Toronto
Ayal M, Seidmann A (2009) An empirical investigation of the value of integrating enterprise information systems: the case of medical imaging informatics. J Manag Inf Syst 26(2):43–68
Balasubramanian P, Kulatilaka N, Storck J (2000) Managing information technology investments using a real-options approach. J Strateg Inf Syst 9(1):39–62
Bamberg G, Krapp M (2016) Is time consistency compatible with risk aversion? Rev Manag Sci 10(2):195–211
Bamberg G, Spremann K (1981) Implications of constant risk aversion. Z Oper Res 25(7):205–224
Bamberg G, Dorfleitner G, Krapp M (2006) Unternehmensbewertung unter Unsicherheit: Zur entscheidungstheoretischen Fundierung der Risikoanalyse. Z Betriebswirtschaft 76(3):287–307
Baskerville R, Cavallari M, Hjort-Madsen K, Pries-Heje J, Sorrentino M, Virili F (2005) Extensible architectures: the strategic value of service-oriented architecture in banking. In: Proceedings of the 13th European conference on information systems, Regensburg
Becker A, Widjaja T, Buxmann P (2011) Value potentials and challenges of service-oriented architectures. Results of an empirical survey from user and vendor perspective. Bus Inf Syst Eng 3(4):199–210
Beimborn D, Joachim N, Weitzel T (2008) Drivers and inhibitors of SOA business value - conceptualizing a research model. In: Proceedings of the 14th Americas conference on information systems, Toronto
Benaroch M, Kauffman RJ (1999) A case for using real options pricing analysis to evaluate information technology project investments. Inf Syst Res 10(1):70–86
Benaroch M, Jeffery M, Kauffman R, Shah S (2007) Option-based risk management: a field study of sequential information technology investment decisions. J Manag Inf Syst 24(2):103–140
Bharadwaj A, Bharadwaj SG, Konsynski BR (1999) Information technology effects on firm performance as measured by Tobin’s q. Manag Sci 45(7):1008–1024
Black F, Scholes M (1973) The pricing of options and corporate liabilities. J Political Econ 81(3):637–654
Boell SK, Cecez-Kecmanovic D (2014) A hermeneutic approach for conducting literature reviews and literature searches. Commun AIS 34(1):257–286
Bradley A (2008) Finding the business value in SOA: a business case framework. In: Symposium/ITxpo 2008, Orlando
Brandl R, Bichler M, Ströbel M (2007) Cost accounting for shared IT infrastructures estimating resource utilization in distributed IT architectures. Wirtschaftsinformatik 49(2):83–94
Braunwarth KS, Friedl B (2010) Towards a financially optimal design of IT services. In: Proceedings of the 31st international conference on information systems, St Louis
Braunwarth KS, Heinrich B (2008) IT-Service-Management - Ein Modell zur Bestimmung der Folgen von Interoperabilitätsstandards auf die Einbindung externer IT-Dienstleister. Wirtschaftsinformatik 50(2):98–110
Brynjolfsson E, Hitt L (1995) Information technology as a factor of production: the role of differences among firms. Econ Innov New Technol 3(4):183–200
Buhl HU, Röglinger M, Stöckl S, Braunwarth KS (2011) Value orientation in process management. Bus Inf Syst Eng 3(3):163–172
Chau PYK, Kuan KKY, Liang TP (2007) Research on IT value: what we have done in Asia and Europe. Eur J Inf Syst 16(3):196–201
Cho W, Shaw MJ (2009) Does IT synergy matter in IT portfolio selection? In: Proceedings of the 30th international conference on information systems, Phoenix
Cho W, Shaw MJ (2013) Portfolio selection model for enhancing information technology synergy. IEEE Trans Eng Manag 60(4):739–749
Choi J, Nazareth DL, Jain HK (2010) Implementing service-oriented architecture in organizations. J Manag Inf Syst 26(4):253–286
Cochrane JH (2005) Asset pricing. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Coenenberg A, Salfeld R (2003) Wertorientierte Unternehmensführung. Schäffer-Poeschel, Stuttgart
Copeland TE, Weston JF, Shastri K (2008) Financial theory and corporate policy. Addison-Wesley, Boston
Cui X, Li D, Wang S, Zhu S (2012) Better than dynamic mean - variance: time inconsistency and free cash flow stream. Math Finance 22(2):346–378
Davis GA (2002) The impact of volatility on firms holding growth options. Eng Econ 47(2):213–231
DeAngelo H (1981) Competition and unanimity. Am Econ Rev 71(1):18–27
Dedrick J, Gurbaxani V, Kraemer KL (2003) Information technology and economic performance: a critical review of the empirical evidence. ACM Comput Surv 35(1):1–28
Dehning B, Richardson VJ (2002) Returns on investments in information technology: a research synthesis. J Inf Syst 16(1):7–30
Dewan S, Min CK (1997) The substitution of information technology for other factors of production: a firm level analysis. Manag Sci 43(12):1660–1675
Diao Y, Bhattacharya K (2008) Estimating business value of IT services through process complexity analysis. In: Proceedings of the 11th IEEE/IFIP network operation and management symposium, Salvador de Bahia
Diepold D, Ullrich C, Wehrmann A, Zimmermann S (2011) Bewertung intertemporaler Abhängigkeiten zwischen IT-Projekten: Anwendung eines realoptionsbasierten Ansatzes unter Berücksichtigung projektspezifischer Risiken. Z Betriebswirtschaft 81(7/8):805–831
Dos Santos BL, Peffers KG, Mauer DC (1993) The impact of information technology investment announcements on the market value of the firm. Inf Syst Res 4(1):1–23
Dutta A (2004) Putting numbers on intangible benefits. In: Proceedings of the 25th international conference on information systems, Washington D.C.
Fichman RG (2004) Real options and IT platform adoption: implications for theory and practice. Inf Syst Res 15(2):132–154
Fridgen G, Moser F (2013) Using IT fashion investments to optimize an IT innovation portfolio’s risk and return. J Decis Syst 22(4):298–318
Geman H, Ohana S (2008) Time-consistency in managing a commodity portfolio: a dynamic risk measure approach. J Bank Finance 32(10):1991–2005
Ghosh S, Li X (2013) A real options model for generalized meta-staged projects - valuing the migration to SOA. Inf Syst Res 24(4):1011–1027
Grefen P, Ludwig H, Dan A, Angelov S (2006) An analysis of web services support for dynamic business process outsourcing. Inf Softw Technol 48(11):1115–1134
Häckel B, Hänsch F (2014) Managing an IT portfolio on a synchronized level or: the costs of partly synchronized investment valuation. J Decis Syst 23(4):388–412
Häckel B, Hänsch F, Isakovic V (2011) Langfristige versus periodische IT-Investitionsbewertung im Rahmen einer wertorientierten Unternehmensführung. In: Proceedings of the 10th international conference on wirtschaftsinformatik, Zürich
Han K, Chang YB, Hahn J (2011) Information technology spillover and productivity: the role of information technology intensity and competition. J Manag Inf Syst 28(1):115–145
Hares J, Royle D (1994) Measuring the value of information technology. Wiley, New York
Harmantzis FC, Tanguturi VP (2007) Investment decisions in the wireless industry applying real options. Telecommun Policy 31(2):107–123
Heffner R, Leganza J, Czarnecki M (2009) SOA is far from dead - but it should be buried. Forrester Research
Hirshleifer J (1965) Investment decision under uncertainty: choice-theoretic approaches. Q J Econ 79(4):509–536
Hitt LM, Brynjolfsson E (1996) Productivity, business profitability, and consumer surplus: three different measures of information technology value. MIS Q 20(2):121–142
Irani Z (2010) Investment evaluation within project management: an information systems perspective. J Oper Res Soc 61(6):917–928
Irani Z, Love PED (2002) Developing a frame of reference for ex-ante IT/IS investment valuation. Eur J Inf Syst 11(1):74–82
Joachim N (2011) A literature review of research on service-oriented architectures (SOA): characteristics, adoption determinants, governance mechanisms, and business impact. In: Proceedings of the 17th Americas conference on information systems, Detroit, paper 339
Joachim N, Beimborn D, Weitzel T (2013) The influence of SOA governance mechanisms on IT flexibility and service reuse. J Strateg Inf Syst 22:86–101
Kaczmarek T, Wecel K (2008) Hype over service oriented architecture continues. Wirtschaftsinformatik 50(1):52–78
Kauffman RJ, Li X (2005) Technology competition and optimal investment timing: a real options perspective. IEEE Trans Eng Manag 52(1):15–29
King WR, He J (2005) Understanding the role and methods of meta-analysis in IS research. Commun AIS 16(1):665–686
Klischewski R, Abubakr R (2010) Can e-government adopters benefit from a technology-first approach? The case of Egypt embarking on service-oriented architecture. In: Proceedings of the 43rd Hawaii international conference on system sciences, Hawaii
Kohlborn T, Korthaus A, Taizan C, Rosemann M (2009) Identification and analysis of business and software services - a consolidated approach. IEEE Trans Serv Comput 2(1):50–64
Kohli R, Grover V (2008) Business value of IT: an essay on expanding research directions to keep up with the times. J Assoc Inf Syst 9(1):23–39
Kontogiannis K, Lewis G, Smith D (2007) The landscape of service-oriented systems: a research perspective for maintenance and reengineering. In: Proceedings of the workshop on service-oriented architecture maintenance, Amsterdam
Krammer A, Heinrich B, Henneberger M, Lautenbacher F (2011) Granularity of services. An economic analysis. Bus Inf Syst Eng 3(6):345–358
Kumar S, Dakshinamoorth V, Krishnan M (2007) Does SOA improve the supply chain? An empirical analysis of the impact of SOA adoption on electronic supply chain performance. In: Proceedings of the 40th Hawaii international conference on system sciences, Hawaii
Kundisch D, Meier M (2011) IT/IS project portfolio selection in the presence of project interactions - review and synthesis of the literature. In: Proceedings of the 10th international conference on wirtschaftsinformatik, Zürich
Lee S, XiangJY Kim JK (2011) Information technology and productivity: empirical evidence from the Chinese electronics industry. Inf Manag 48(2/3):79–87
Levy Y, Ellis TJ (2006) A systems approach to conduct an effective literature review in support of information systems research. Inf Sci J 9:181–212
Li X (2009) Preemptive learning, competency traps, and information technology: a real options analysis. IEEE Trans Eng Manag 56(4):650–662
Lintner J (1965) The valuation of risk assets and the selection of risky investments in stock portfolios and capital budgets. Rev Econ Stat 47(1):13–37
Luthria H, Rabhi F (2009) Using service oriented computing for competitive advantage. In: Proceedings of the 15th Americas conference on information systems, San Francisco
Markowitz HM (1959) Portfolio selection: efficient diversification of investments. Yale University Press, New Haven
Mata FJ, Fuerst WL, Barney JB (1995) Information technology and sustained competitive advantage: a resource-based analysis. MIS Q 19(4):487–505
Melville N, Kraemer K, Gurbaxani V (2004) Information technology and organizational performance: an integrative model of IT business value. MIS Q 28(2):283–322
Millard DE, Howard Y, Abbas N, Davis HC, Gilbert L, Wills GB, Walters RJ (2009) Pragmatic web service design: an agile approach with the service responsibility and interaction design method. Comput Sci Res Dev 24(4):173–184
Moitra D, Ganesh J (2005) Web services and flexible business processes: towards the adaptive enterprise. Inf Manag 42(7):921–933
Müller B, Viering G, Ahlemann F, Riempp G (2007) Towards understanding the sources of the economic potential of service-oriented architecture: findings from the automotive and banking industry. In: Proceedings of the 15th European conference on information systems, St. Gallen
Murphy KE, Simon SJ (2001) Using cost benefit analysis for enterprise resource planning project evaluation: a case for including intangibles. In: Proceedings of the 34th Hawaii international conference on system sciences, Hawaii
Oh LB, Leong YX, Teo HH, Ravichandran T (2007) Service-oriented architecture and organizational integration: an empirical study of IT-enabled sustained competitive advantage. In: Proceedings of the 28th international conference on information systems, Montreal
Orlikowski WJ, Iacono CS (2001) Desperately seeking the ‘IT’ in IT research. A call to theorizing the IT artifact. Inf Syst Res 12(2):121–134
Papazoglou MP (2008) Service-oriented computing: a research roadmap. Int J Coop Inf Syst 17(2):223–255
Peacock E, Tanniru M (2005) Activity-based justification of IT investments. Inf Manag 42:415–424
Pratt JW (1964) Risk aversion in the small and in the large. Econometrica 30(1/2):122–136
Probst F, Buhl HU (2012) Supplier portfolio management for IT services considering diversification effects. Bus Inf Syst Eng 4(2):71–83
Rai A, Sambamurthy V (2006) Editorial notes - the growth of interest in service management: opportunities for information systems scholars. Inf Syst Res 17(4):327–331
Rai A, Patnayakuni R, Patnayakuni N (1997) Technology investment and business performance. Commun ACM 40(7):89–97
Renkema TJW, Berghout EW (1997) Methodologies for information systems investment evaluation at the proposal stage: a comparative review. Inf Softw Technol 39(1):1–13
Ross JW, Beath CM (2002) Beyond the business case: new approaches to IT investment. MIT Sloan Manag Rev 43(2):51–59
Rowe F (2014) What literature review is not: diversity, boundaries and recommendations. Eur J Inf Syst 23:241–255
Schelp J, Winter R (2007) Towards a methodology for service construction. In: Proceedings of the 40th Hawaii international conference on system sciences, Hawaii
Schryen G (2013) Revisiting IS business value research: what we already know, what we still need to know, and how we can get there. Eur J Inf Syst 22(2):139–169
Schryen G, Bodenstein C (2010) A decision-theoretic foundation of IS business value research. In: Proceedings of the 18th European conference on information systems, Pretoria
SCHUFA (2015) Access to SCHUFA services. https://www.schufa.de/en/en/produkteundservices_en/anbindungandieschufa_1/anbindungandieschufa.jsp. Accessed 26 Aug 2015
Schwartz EJ, Zozaya-Gorostiza C (2003) Investment under uncertainty in information technology: acquisition and development projects. Manag Sci 49(1):57–70
Schwarz A, Mehta M, Johnson N, Chin W (2007) Understanding frameworks and reviews: a commentary to assist us in moving our field forward by analyzing our past. Data Base Adv Inf Syst 38(3):29–50
Sharpe WF (1964) Capital asset prices: a theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk. J Finance 19(3):425–442
Sircar S, Turnbow JL, Bordoloi B (2000) A framework for assessing the relationship between information technology investments and firm performance. J Manag Inf Syst 16(4):69–97
Smith JE, Nau RF (1995) Valuing risky projects: option pricing theory and decision analysis. Manag Sci 41(5):795–816
Soh C, Markus ML (1995) How IT creates business value: a process theory synthesis. In: Proceedings of the 16th International conference on information systems, Amsterdam
Strotz RH (1955) Myopia and inconsistency in dynamic utility maximization. Rev Econ Stud 23(3):165–180
Sylla C, Wen HJ (2002) A conceptual framework for evaluation of information technology investments. Int J Technol Manag 24(2–3):236–261
Tewary K, Kosalge P, Motwani J (2009) Piloting service oriented architecture: a case study in the oil industry. In: Proceedings of the 15th Americas conference on information systems, San Francisco
Thomas O, vom Brocke J (2010) A value-driven approach to the design of service oriented information systems - making use of conceptual models. Inf Syst E Bus Manag 8(1):67–97
Trkman P, Kovacic A, Popovic A (2011) SOA adoption phases: a case study. Bus Inf Syst Eng 3(4):211–220
Ullrich C (2013) Valuation of IT investments using real options theory. Bus Inf Syst Eng 5(5):331–341
Verhoef C (2002) Quantitative IT portfolio management. Sci Comput Program 45(1):1–96
Verhoef C (2005) Quantifying the value of IT-investments. Sci Comput Program 56(1):315–342
Viering G, Legner C, Ahlemann F (2009) The (lacking) business perspective on SOA - critical themes in SOA research. In: Proceedings of the 9th international conference on wirtschaftsinformatik, Vienna
vom Brocke J, Sonnenberg C (2007) Serviceorientiertes Prozesscontrolling - Unternehmensindividuelle Wirtschaftlichkeitsrechnungen zur Nutzung serviceorientierter Architekturen bei der Prozessgestaltung. In: Nissen V, Petsch M, Schorcht H (eds) Service-orientierte Architekturen: Chancen und Herausforderungen bei der Flexibilisierung und Integration von Unternehmensprozessen. Gabler, Wiesbaden, pp 185–204
vom Brocke J, Sonnenberg C, Thomas O (2008) Towards an economic justification of service oriented architectures - measuring the financial impact. In: Proceedings of the 14th Americas conference on information systems, Toronto
vom Brocke J, Sonnenberg C, Simons A (2009) Value-oriented information systems design: the concept of potentials modelling and its application to service-oriented architectures. Bus Inf Syst Eng 1(3):223–233
von Neumann J, Morgenstern O (1947) Theory of games and economic behavior. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Webster J, Watson RT (2002) Analyzing the past to prepare for the future. Writing a literature review. MIS Q 26(2):xiii–xxiii
Wehrmann A, Heinrich B, Seifert F (2006) Quantitatives IT-Portfoliomanagement: Risiken von IT-Investitionen wertorientiert steuern. Wirtschaftsinformatik 48(4):234–245
Wilhelm J (1989) On stakeholders’ unanimity. In: Bamberg G, Spremann K (eds) Agency theory, information, and incentives. Springer, Berlin, pp 179–204
Zimmermann S (2008a) Governance im IT Portfoliomanagement - Ein Ansatz zur Berücksichtigung von Strategic Alignment bei der Bewertung von IT. Wirtschaftsinformatik 50(5):357–365
Zimmermann S (2008b) IT-Portfoliomanagement - Ein Konzept zur Bewertung und Gestaltung von IT. Inf Spektrum 31(5):460–468
Zimmermann S, Katzmarzik A, Kundisch D (2012) IT sourcing portfolio management for IT services providers - an approach for using modern portfolio theory to allocate software development projects to available sites. Data Base Adv Inf Syst 43(1):24–45
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Accepted after three revisions by Prof. Bichler.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Buhl, H.U., Häckel, B.S., Probst, F. et al. On the Ex Ante Valuation of IT Service Investments. Bus Inf Syst Eng 58, 415–432 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12599-016-0435-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12599-016-0435-3