Abstract
Testicular tissue cryopreservation (TTCP) aims to preserve the future option of genetic reproduction for prepubescent cancer patients who are at risk of infertility as a result of their cancer therapies. This technology is experimental and currently only offered in the research context. As TTCP moves towards becoming more widely available, it is imperative that healthcare providers recognize the complex ethical issues surrounding this technology. This scoping review study identifies and assesses the range and depth of ethical concerns related to this testicular tissue cryopreservation technology. At present, no such scoping review of ethical concerns exists in the TTCP literature. The forty-three full-text articles included in this study yielded twenty-two different ethical considerations discussed in relation to TTCP. It was observed that these ethical considerations fit within a mainstream Principlism approach to bioethics. Accordingly, there are ethical gaps in the TTCP literature that can be identified with alternative moral lenses. In particular, it was found that ethical concerns related to context and relational aspects of identity were absent in nearly all ethical examinations of TTCP. Furthermore, only 9 per cent of articles reviewed in this study focused primarily on the ethics of TTCP, thus demonstrating a need for further in depth ethical analyses of this technology. The results of this study are important for supporting the ethical provision of TTCP and can contribute to policy and guideline development. The findings of this study demonstrate the need for greater depth and diversity in analyses of ethical considerations related to this technology.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, R.A., R.T. Mitchell, T.W. Kelsey, N. Spears, E.E. Telfer, and W.H.B. Wallace. 2015. Cancer treatment and gonadal function: Experimental and established strategies for fertility preservation in children and young adults. The Lancet Diabetes Endocrinology 3(7): 556–567.
Arksey, H., and L. O’Malley. 2005. Scoping studies: Towards a methodological framework. International Journal of Social Research Methodology 8(1): 19–32.
Babayev, S., E. Arslan, S. Kogan, F. Moy, and K. Oktay. 2013. Evaluation of ovarian and testicular tissue cryopreservation in children undergoing gonadotoxic therapies. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 30(1): 3–9.
Bahadur, G., and D. Ralph. 1999. Gonadal tissue cryopreservation in boys with pediatric cancers. Human Reproduction 14(1): 11–17.
Bahadur, G., R. Chatterjee, and D. Ralph. 2000. Testicular tissue cryopreservation in boys: Ethical and legal issues. Human Reproduction 15(6): 1416–1420.
Beauchamp, T., and J. Childress. 1979. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Brougham, M.F.H., C.J.H. Kelnar, R.M. Sharpe, and W.H.B. Wallace. 2003. Male fertility following childhood cancer: Current concepts and future therapies. Asian Journal of Andrology 5(4): 325–337.
Campo-Engelstein, L. 2013. Offering testicular cryopreservation to boys: The increasing importance of biological fatherhood. The American Journal of Bioethics 12(3): 39–40.
Clark A.T., B.T. Phillips, and K.E. Orwig. 2011. Fruitful progress to fertility: Male fertility in the test tube. Nature Medicine 17(12): 1564–1565.
Clarke, D.L. 2009. Moral Principlism alone is insufficient, and traditional moral theories remain important for practical ethics. South African Journal of Bioethics and Law 2(2): 54–58.
Clouser, K.D., and B. Gert. 1990. A critique of principlism. The Journal of Medicine & Philosophy 15(2): 219–236.
De Roo, C., K. Tilleman, G. T’Sjoen, and P. De Sutter. 2016. Fertility options in transgender people. International Review of Psychiatry 28(1): 112–119.
Di Pietro, M.L., and A.A. Teleman. 2013. Cryopreservation of testicular tissue in pediatrics: Practical and ethical issues. The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine 26(15): 1524–1527.
Dillon, K.E., and C.R. Gracia. 2012. Pediatric and young adult patients and oncofertility. Current Treatment Options in Oncology 13(2):161–173.
Fernbach, A., B. Lockart, C.L. Armus et al. 2014. Evidence-based recommendations for fertility preservation options for inclusion in treatments for pediatric and adolescent patients diagnosed with cancer. Journal of Pediatric Oncology Nursing 31(4): 211–222.
Galvin, K.M., and M.L. Clayman. 2010. Whose future is it? Ethical family decision making about daughters’ treatment in the oncofertility context. Cancer Treatment and Research 156: 429–445.
Gies, I., J. De Schepper, and H. Trounay. 2015. Progress and prospects for fertility preservation in prepubertal boys with cancer. Current Opinion in Endrocrinology, Diabetes and Obesity 22(3): 203–208.
Ginsberg, J.P., C.A. Carlson, K. Lin, et al. 2010. An experimental protocol for fertility preservation in prepubertal boys recently diagnosed with cancer: A report of acceptability and safety. Andrology 25(1): 37–41.
Ginsberg, J.P. 2011. New advances in fertility preservation for pediatric cancer patients. Current Opinion Pediatrics 23(1): 9–13.
Ginsberg, J.P., Y. Li, C.A. Carlson et al. 2014. Testicular tissue cryopreservation in prepubertal male children: An analysis of parental decision-making. Pediatric Blood and Cancer 61(9): 1673–1678.
Goossens, E., D. Van Saen, and H. Tournaye. 2013. Spermatogonial stem cell preservation and transplantation: From research to clinic. Human Reproduction 28(4): 897–907.
Heath, J.A., and C.J. Stern. 2006. Fertility preservation in children newly diagnosed with cancer: Existing standards of practice in Australia and New Zealand. Medical Journal of Australia 185(10): 538–541.
Holoch, P., and M. Wald. 2011. Current options for preservation of fertility in the male. Fertility Sterility 96(2): 286–290.
Hovatta, O. 2001. Cryopreservation of testicular tissue in young cancer patients. Human Reproduction Update 7(4): 378–383.
Jahnukainen, K., J. Ehmcke, O. Söder, and S. Schlatt. 2006. Clinical potential and putative risks of fertility preservation in children using gonadal tissue or germline stem cells. Pediatric Research 59: 40R–47R.
Kinahan K.E., A. Didwania, and C.L. Nieman. 2007. Childhood cancer: Fertility and psychosocial implications. Cancer Treatment and Research 138: 191–200.
Klipstein, S., and M.E. Fallat. 2013. Applying the experience of ovarian tissue cryopreservation to testicular tissue cryopreservation: What the girls have taught us. The American Journal of Bioethics 13(3:) 44–46.
Marzillano, A., and A. Moyer. 2013. An additional consideration regarding expanding access to testicular tissue cryopreservation: Infertility and social stigma. The American Journal of Bioethics 13(3): 48–50.
Mertes, H., and G. Guido Pennings. 2013. Testicular tissue cryopreservation: Combining access with safeguards. The American Journal of Bioethics 13(3): 46–48.
Mitchell, R.R., P.T.K. Saunders, R.M. Sharpe, CJ.H. Kelnar, and W.H.B. Wallace. 2009. Male fertility and strategies for fertility preservation following childhood cancer. In Endocrine Development, Vol. 15, 101–134. Karger Publishers.
Murphy, T.F. 2010. Parents’ choices in banking boys’ testicular tissue. Journal of Medical Ethics 36(12): 806e–809.
Pacey, A.A., and C. Eiser. 2014. The importance of fertility preservation in cancer patients. Expert Review of Anticancer Therapy 14(5): 487–489.
Picton, H.M., C. Wyns, R.A. Anderson, et al. 2015. A European perspective on testicular tissue cryopreservation for fertility preservation in prepubertal and adolescent boys. Human Reproduction 30(11): 2463–2475.
Rawlinson, M.C. 2001. The concept of a feminist bioethics. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26(4): 405–416.
Revel, A., and S. Revel-Vilk. 2008. Pediatric fertility preservation: Is it time to offer testicular tissue cryopreservation? Molecular and Cellular Endocrinology 282(1): 143–149.
Rogers, A. 2013. Restricting access to reproductive uses of minors’ stored gonadal tissue. The American Journal of Bioethics 13(3): 41–42.
Rumrill, P.D., S.M. Fitzgerald, and W.R. Merchant. 2010. Using scoping literature reviews as a means of understanding and interpreting existing literature. Work: A Journal of Prevention, Assessment & Rehabilitation 35(3): 399–404.
Ruutianen, T., S. Miler, A. Caplan and J.P. Ginsberg. 2013. Expanding access to testicular tissue cryopreservation: an analysis by analogy. The American Journal of Bioethics 13(3): 28–35.
Sadri-Adrekani, B., and A. Atala. 2014. Testicular tissue cryopreservation and spermatogonial stem cell transplantation to restore fertility: From bench to bedside. Stem Cell Research & Therapy 5(3): 68–77.
Satkoske, V.B., and L.S. Parker. 2013. Preserving testicular tissue and a boy’s open reproductive future. The American Journal of Bioethics 13(3): 36–37.
Sauvat, F., N. Binart, C. Poirot, and S. Sarnacki. 2009. Preserving fertility in prepubertal children. Hormone Research 71(S1):82–86.
Schlatt, S., J. Ehmcke, and K. Jahnukainen. 2009. Testicular stem cells for fertility preservation: Preclinical studies on male germ cell transplantation and testicular grafting. Pediatric Blood and Cancer 53(2): 274–280.
Walker, M.U. 2008. Moral understandings: A feminist study in ethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Wallace, H.B., R.A. Anderson, and D.S. Irvine. 2005. Fertility preservation for young patients with cancer: Who is at risk and what can be offered? Lancet Oncology 6(4): 209–218.
Wallace, H.B. 2011. Oncofertility and preservation of reproductive capacity in children and young adults. Cancer 117(S10): 2301–2310.
Wyns, C., M. Curaba, S. Petit, et al. 2011. Management of fertility preservation in prepubertal patients: 5 years’ experience at the Catholic University of Louvain. Human Reproduction 26(4): 737–747.
Wyns, C., M. Curaba, B. Martinez-Madrid, A. Van Langendonckt, W. François-Xavier, and J. Donnez. 2007. Spermatogonial survival after cryopreservation and short-term orthotopic immature human cryptorchid testicular tissue grafting to immunodeficient mice. Human Reproduction 22(6): 1603–1611.
Zakak, N.N. 2009. Fertility issues of childhood cancer survivors: The role of the pediatric nurse practitioner in fertility preservation. Association of Pediatric Hematology/Oncology Nurses 26(1): 48–59.
Acknowledgements
Funding in support of this research was provided by the Canada Research Chair in Bioethics and Philosophy on “Impact Ethics: Making a Difference.” I also gratefully acknowledge the support of the Brocher Foundation in Hermance, Switzerland (www.brocher.ch) which provided an idyllic setting in which to complete my writing.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Petropanagos, A. Testicular Tissue Cryopreservation and Ethical Considerations: A Scoping Review. Bioethical Inquiry 14, 217–228 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-017-9781-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-017-9781-1