Abstract
Purpose
Devices that condense and disinfect water vapour to provide chilled drinking water in office environments, so-called ‘air water generators’ (AWGs), are being marketed as environmentally friendly alternatives to the traditional bottled water cooler. We sought to examine this claim.
Methods
The approach adopted was a preliminary life cycle assessment with performance indicators for the use of energy and water and the emission of greenhouse gases. We compared an AWG with its main market competitor, the traditional bottled water cooler and a simple refrigerator containing a jug of water. Modelling was based on Australian conditions and energy supply. To manage possible scope uncertainty, we borrowed the idea of ‘triangulation’ as defined in the social sciences.
Results and discussion
We found that without a renewable energy supply, the claim of environmental superiority is not supported by quantitative analysis. For each indicator, the AWG's score was typically two to four times higher than the alternatives. Energy consumption was the key issue driving all three indicators.
Conclusions
Considering the principal environmental issues related to these systems, air-to-water machines significantly underperform bottled water coolers. A simple refrigerator has the capacity to perform multiple functions and therefore outperform both the bottled and atmospheric water options once allocation of burdens is considered. These conclusions are supported by all three perspectives examined to manage uncertainty.
References
Arvidsson R, Fransson K, Fröling M, Svanström M, Molander S (2012) Energy use indicators in energy and life cycle assessments of biofuels: review and recommendations. J Clean Prod 31:54–61
Blackburn N, Peters G (2009) Atmospheric water generation - an environmentally friendly alternative to bottled water? 6th Australian Conference on LCA, Melbourne, 16-19 February, Australian Life Cycle Assessment Society
Boulding K (1956) General systems theory - the skeleton of science. Manag Sci 2(3):197–208
Brundrett GW (1987) Handbook of dehumidification technology. London, Butterworths
Commonwealth of Australia (2010) E3 Equipment Energy Efficiency. 2010, at www.energyrating.com.au
Copeland K, Sherman S, Kendeigh C, Kalkwarf H, Saelens B (2012) Societal values and policies may curtail preschool children's physical activity in child care centres. Pediatrics 129:265–274
Crabb A (2011) The great carbon tax secret: who are the Misfortune 500? viewed 10 Dec 2011, at http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-07-12/the-great-carbon-tax-secret-who-are-the-misfortune/2790974
De Wolff K (2007) Marketing and Materiality in the Normalization of Bottled Water. School of Sociology, Queen's University, Belfast. Masters Thesis
DECC (2011) Planning our electric future: a White Paper for secure, affordable and low-carbon electricity, Department of Energy and Climate Change, UK, at http://www.decc.gov.uk/assets/decc/11/policy-legislation/EMR/2176-emr-white-paper.pdf (accessed June 2012), ISBN: 9780101809924
Doria M (2006) Bottled water versus tap water: understanding consumers' preferences. J Wat Health 4:271–276
Gentile T (2007) Proposed bottled water ‘bans’ misguided. Viewed 10 August 2008, at www.australianbeverages.org
Gill J (2005) The future of water in a drying climate. CA Business Forum viewed May, 2009, at http://www.watercorporation.com.au/_files/presentations/20050512.pdf
Global Sources (2011) Air Water Maker. Viewed October 24, 2011, at http://www.hendrx.manufacturer.globalsources.com/si/6008823530723/pdtl/Atmospheric-water/1042384173/Air-Water-Maker.htm
Guiterrez Y, Diaz B, Hopp M (2008) An analysis of some environmental consequences of European electrical and electronic waste regulations. Res Cons Recyc 52:481–495
Hanssen O, Rukke E, Saugen B, Kolstad J, Hafrom P, von Krogh L, Raadal H, Rönning A, Wigum K (2007) The environmental effectiveness of the beverage sector in Norway in a factor 10 perspective. Int J Life Cycle Assess 12(4):257–265
Harvey L (2006) A handbook on low-energy buildings and district-energy systems: fundamentals, techniques and examples. Earthscan Publications Ltd, London, ISBN: 9781844072439
Horne R, Grant T, Verghese K (2009) Life cycle assessment - principles, practise and prospects. CSIRO Publishing, Collingwood, ISBN: 9780643094529
Huijbregts M, Norris G, Bretz R, Ciroth A, Maurice B, von Bahr B, Weidema B, de Beaufort A (2001) Framework for modelling data uncertainty in life cycle inventories. Int J Life Cycle Assess 6(3):127–132
Island Sky (2007) Production Chart Skywater14. April 2008, at www.islandsky.com/production_14.html
Jungbluth N (2006) Comparison of the Environmental Impact of Drinking Water vs. Bottled Mineral Water. Viewed 23/9/08, at http://aquadoc.typepad.com/waterwired/files/bottled_water_impact_lca.pdf
Loughnane B (2010) The Coalition’s Direct Action Plan. Viewed June, 2012, at http://www.liberal.org.au/Issues/Environment.aspx
Lundie S, Peters G, Beavis P (2004) Life cycle assessment for sustainable metropolitan water systems planning – options for ecological sustainability. Environ Sci Technol 38(13):3465–3473
Lundie S, Peters G, Beavis P (2005) Quantitative systems analysis as a strategic planning approach for metropolitan water service providers. Wat Sci Technol 52(9):11–20
Lundie S, Peters G, Ashbolt N, Lai E, Livingston D (2006) A sustainability framework for the Australian water industry. Water 33(7):83–88
Neverfail (2011) Ordering. Viewed 23 August 2011, at http://selfservice.neverfail.com.au/NewOrder/ordering.htm
PAS2050 (2008) Specification for the assessment of the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of goods and services. British Standards, ISBN: 978 0 580 50978 0
Peters G (2009) Popularise or publish. Int J Life Cycle Assess 14(6):503–507
Peters G, Wiedemann S, Rowley HV, Tucker R (2010) Accounting for water use in Australian red meat production. Int J Life Cycle Assess 15(3):311–320
Pfister S, Koehler A, Hellweg S (2009) Assessing the environmental impacts of freshwater consumption in LCA. Environ Sci Technol 43:4098–4104
Rafico (2011) Air Makes Water: Save our environment with water from the air. Viewed 23 August 2011, at http://www.royalsprings.com.au/product/fn_pdf/247/information_proposal_for_air_makes_water.pdf
Reed T (2011) “Energy shock: confronting higher prices.” viewed October 2011, at www.aigroup.com.au
Rowley HV, Peters G (2009) A hybrid LCA model for comparison with conventional methodologies in Australia. Int J Life Cycle Assess 14(6):508–516
Schulz M, Short M, Peters G (2012) A streamlined sustainability assessment tool for improved decision-making in the urban water industry. Integr Environ Assess Manag 8:183–193
Short M, Peirson W, Peters G, Cox R (2012) Challenges in adapting water delivery systems to climate change—a review. Water Res Manag 26:1953–1981
USEPA (2008) Energy Star Water Cooler. Viewed 23 August 2008, at www.energystar.gov/ia/business/bulk_purchasing/bpsavings_calc/CalculatorBulkPurchasingWaterCooler.xls
White S, Mitchell C (2003) Forecasting and backcasting for sustainable urban water futures. Water 30(5):25–30
Wyrwich K, Metz S, Kroenke K, Tierney T, Babu A, Wolinsky F (2007) Triangulating patient and clinician perspectives on clinically important differences in health-related quality of life. Health Serv Res 42(6 P1):2257–2274
Acknowledgment
The authors wish to thank John Peters for insightful conversations regarding electrical engineering principles and technology.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Responsible editor: Rainer Zah
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Peters, G.M., Blackburn, N.J. & Armedion, M. Environmental assessment of air to water machines—triangulation to manage scope uncertainty. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18, 1149–1157 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-013-0568-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-013-0568-2