Abstract
The rigid recoil of a crystal is the accepted mechanism for the Mössbauer effect. It’s at odds with the special theory of relativity which does not allow perfectly rigid bodies. The standard model of particle physics which includes QED should not allow any signals to be transmitted faster than the speed of light. If perturbation theory can be used, then the X-ray emitted in a Mössbauer decay must come from a single nuclear decay vertex at which the 4-momentum is exactly conserved in a Feynman diagram. Then the 4-momentum of the final state Mössbauer nucleus must be slightly off the mass shell. This off-shell behavior would be followed by subsequent diffusion of momentum throughout the crystal to bring the nucleus back onto the mass shell and the crystal to a final relaxed state in which it moves rigidly with the appropriate recoil velocity. This mechanism explains the Mössbauer effect at the microscopic level and reconciles it with relativity. Because off-mass-shell quantum mechanics is required, the on-mass-shell theories developed originally for the Mössbauer effect are inadequate. Another possibility is that that the recoil response involves a non-perturbative effect in the standard model which could allow for a non-local instantaneous momentum transfer between the crystal and the decay (or absorption), as proposed for example by Preparata and others in super-radiance theory. The recoil time of the crystal is probably not instantaneous, and if it could be measured, one could distinguish between various theories. An experiment is proposed in this paper to measure this time. The idea is to measure the total energy radiated due to bremsstrahlung from a charged Mössbauer crystal which has experienced a recoil. Using Larmor’s formula, along with corrections to it, allows one to design an experiment. The favored idea is to use many small nano-spheres of Mössbauer-active metals, whose outer surfaces are charged. The energy radiated then varies as the charge squared divided by the recoil time. This can then be measured with the extreme sensitivity available in Mössbauer experiments. If it turns out that experiments prove the need for off-mass-shell theory, then this would have profound implications for all of condensed matter physics. It would mean that an off-mass-shell theory like those considered by Stueckelberg, Horwitz, Piron, Greenberger, and many others are required to describe nature. The inclusion of these would be a major shift in the foundations. It would mean that there are new dynamic variables—the rest masses of particles. The ability to measure the diffusion relaxation time should prove useful also in chemical analysis, and provide a new class of analytical methods for material science. This problem is also interesting because the Mössbauer effect is a phenomenon where the solid-state environment dramatically and indisputably influences the probability of a nuclear process.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bohm, D., Weinstein, M.: The self-oscillations of a charged particle. Phys. Rev. 74(12), 1789–1798 (1948)
Bressani, T., Del Giudice, E., Preparata, G.: What makes a crystal “stiff” enough for the Mössbauer effect? Il Nuovo Cimento D 14(3), 345–349 (1992)
Chen, Y.-L., Yang, D.-P.: Mössbauer Effect in Lattice Dynamics: Experimental Techniques and Applications. Wiley, New York (2007)
Cheng, Y., Xia, B., Liu, Y.-N., Jin, Q.-X.: Rhodium Mössbauer effect generated by bremsstrahlung excitation. Chin. Phys. Lett. 22, 2530–2533 (2005)
Davydov, A.V., Isaev, Y.N., Kalantarov, V.D., Korotkov, M.M., Migachev, V.V., Novozhilov, Y.B., Stepanov, A.M.: Gravitational gamma spectrometer for studying the gamma resonance of the long-lived isomer 103mrh. arXiv:1512.08576 [nucl-ex, physics:physics], (2015)
Fanchi, J.R.: Parametrized Relativistic Quantum Theory. Springer, New York (1993)
Fock, V.: Die eigenzeit in der klassischen und in der quantenmechanik. Phys. Z. Sowjetunion 12, 404–425 (1937)
Franklin, J.: Rigid body motion in special relativity. Found. Phy. 43(12), 1489–1501 (2013)
Frauenfelder, H.: The Mossbauer Effect: A Review, with a Collection of Reprints. Benjamin, W.A, New York (1962)
Fultz, B.: Characterization of materials. In: Kaufmann, E. (ed.) Mössbauer Spectrometry. Wiley, New York (2011)
Gibb, I.C.: Principles of Mössbauer Spectroscopy. Springer, Berlin (2013)
Goedecke, G.H.: Classically radiationless motions and possible implications for quantum theory. Phys. Rev. 135, B281–B288 (1964)
Greenberger, D.M.: Theory of particles with variable mass. I. Formalism. J. Math. Phys. 11(8), 2329–2340 (1970)
Greenberger, D.M.: Theory of particles with variable mass. II. Some physical consequences. J. Math. Phys. 11(8), 2341–2347 (1970)
Greenberger, D.M.: Some useful properties of a theory of variable mass particles. J. Math. Phys. 15(4), 395 (1974)
Greenberger, D.M.: Wavepackets for particles of indefinite mass. J. Math. Phys. 15(4), 406 (1974)
Greenwood, N.N., Gibb, T.C.: The Mössbauer effect. In: Siegbahn, K. (ed.) Mössbauer Spectroscopy, pp. 1–16. Springer, Berlin (1971)
Horwitz, L.P., Piron, C.: Relativistic dynamics. Helv. Phys. Acta 46(3), 316–326 (1973)
Horwitz, L.: A statistical mechanical model for mass stability in the SHP theory. arXiv:1607.03742 [physics], (2016)
Horwitz, L.P.: Relativistic Quantum Mechanics. Springer, Dordrecht (2015)
Land, M.: Speeds of light and mass stability in Stueckelberg–Horwitz–Piron electrodynamics. arXiv:1604.01638 [hep-th, physics:physics], (2016)
Lipkin, H.J.: Some simple features of the Mössbauer effect. Ann. Phys. Phys. 9(2), 332–339 (1960)
Lipkin, H.J.: Quantum Mechanics: New Approaches to Selected Topics. Courier Corporation, Chelmsford (2007)
Lipkin, H.J.: Quantum Mechanics: New Approaches to Selected Topics. Courier Corporation, Chelmsford (2014)
Lippmann, B.A., Schwinger, J.: Variational principles for scattering processes. I. Phys. Rev. 79(3), 469–480 (1950)
Long, G.J., Grandjean, F.: Mössbauer Spectroscopy Applied to Inorganic Chemistry. Springer Science & Business Media, Dordrecht (2013)
Mørup, S.: Mössbauer effect in small particles. Hyperfine Interact. 60, 959–973 (1990)
Mössbauer, R.L.: Kernresonanzfluoreszenz von Gammastrahlung in Ir191. Zeitschrift für Physik 151(2), 124–143 (1958)
Oerter, R.: The Theory of Almost Everything: The Standard Model, the Unsung Triumph of Modern Physics. Plume, New York (2006)
Pearle, P.: When can a classical electron accelerate without radiating? Found. Phys. 8(11–12), 879–891 (1978)
Preparata, G.: QED Coherence in Matter. World Scientific, Singapore (1995)
Rohrlich, F.: The dynamics of a charged sphere and the electron. Am. J. Phys. 65(11), 1051–1056 (1997)
Schott, G.A.: The electromagnetic field of a moving uniformly and rigidly electrified sphere and its radiationless orbits. Lond. Edinb. Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci. 15(100), 752–761 (1933)
Sharma, V.K., Klingelhofer, G., Nishida, T.: Mossbauer Spectroscopy: Applications in Chemistry, Biology, and Nanotechnology. Wiley, Garden City (2013)
Stevens, J.S., Dunlap, B.D.: Nuclear moments and moment ratios as determined by Mössbauer spectroscopy. J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 5(4), 1093–1122 (1976)
Stueckelberg, E.: La signification du temps propre en mécanique ondulatoire. Helv. Phys. Acta 14, 322–323 (1941)
Stueckelberg, E.: Remarque à propos de la création de paires de particules en théorie de la relativité. Helv. Phys. Acta 14, 588–594 (1941)
Weisskopf, V.: Selected topics in theoretical physics. In: Brittin, W.E., et al. (eds.) Lectures in Theoretical Physics, pp. 54–105. Interscience, New York (1961)
Yaghjian, A.: Relativistic dynamics of a charged sphere: updating the LorentzAbraham model. Technical Report RL-TR-92-46, Rome Laboratory, Air Force Systems Command, Griffiss Air Force Base, New York pp. 13441-5700 (1992)
Yaghjian, A.: Relativistic Dynamics of a Charged Sphere: Updating the Lorentz-Abraham Model, 2nd edn. Springer, Berlin (2005)
Acknowledgements
I would like to acknowledge useful discussions and correspondence with Lawrence Horwitz, Martin Land, Vladimir Kresin, and Robert Perlmutter.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Davidson, M. On the Mössbauer Effect and the Rigid Recoil Question. Found Phys 47, 327–354 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-017-0064-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-017-0064-9