Abstract
Ecologists attempt to understand the diversity of life with mathematical models. Often, mathematical models contain simplifying idealizations designed to cope with the blooming, buzzing confusion of the natural world. This strategy frequently issues in models whose predictions are inaccurate. Critics of theoretical ecology argue that only predictively accurate models are successful and contribute to the applied work of conservation biologists. Hence, they think that much of the mathematical work of ecologists is poor science. Against this view, I argue that model building is successful even when models are predictively inaccurate for at least three reasons: models allow scientists to explore the possible behaviors of ecological systems; models give scientists simplified means by which they can investigate more complex systems by determining how the more complex system deviates from the simpler model; and models give scientists conceptual frameworks through which they can conduct experiments and fieldwork. Critics often mistake the purposes of model building, and once we recognize this, we can see their complaints are unjustified. Even though models in ecology are not always accurate in their assumptions and predictions, they still contribute to successful science.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
H. Andrewartha C. Birch (1954) The Distribution of and Abundance of Animals University of Chicago Press Chicago
F.S. Bodenheimer (1928) ArticleTitleWelche Faktoren regulieren die Individuenzahl einer Insekternart in der Natur? Biologisches Zentralblatt 48 714–739
R. Boyd, P. Richerson. 1988. Simple models of complex phenomena. In: J. Dupre (eds). The Latest of the Best. MIT Press
R. Brandon (1990) Adaptation and Environment Princerton University Press Princeton
R. Brandon (1993) Concepts and Methods in Evolutionary Biology Cambridge University Press Cambridge
N. Cartwright (1995) The Dappled World Cambridge University Press New York
T. Case (2000) An Illustrated Guide to Theoretical Ecology Cambridge University Press Cambridge
H. Caswell (1988) ArticleTitleTheory and Models in Ecology: A Different Perspective Ecol. Model. 43 33–44 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0304-3800(88)90071-3
G. Cooper (1990) The explanatory tools of theoretical population biology PSA 1990 Vol. 2 Philosophy of Science Association East Lansing
G. Cooper (1993) ArticleTitleThe competition controversy in ecology Biol. Philos. 8 IssueID4 359–384 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00857684
J.M. Cushing et al. (2003) Chaos in Ecology: Experimental Nonlinear Dynamics Academic Press London
D.L. DeAngelis (1975) ArticleTitleStability and connectance in food web models Ecology 55 238–243
S. Downes (1992) ArticleTitleThe importance of models in theorizing: a deflationary semantic view PSA 1992 1 142–153
M.R. Gardner W.R. Ashby (1970) ArticleTitleConnectance of largedynamical (Cybernetic) systems: Critical values for stability Nature 228 784 Occurrence Handle10.1038/228784a0 Occurrence Handle5472974
G.F. Gause (1935) The Struggle for Existence Williams and Wilkins Baltimore
R. Giere (1988) Explaining Science University of Chicago Press Chicago
R. Giere (1999) Science Without Laws University of Chicago press Chicago
M. Gilpin (1975) ArticleTitleStability of feasible predator-prey systems Nature 254 137–139 Occurrence Handle10.1038/254137a0
P. Godfrey-Smith (2003) Theory and Reality University of Chicago Press Chicago
J. Griesmer (1990) Material models in biology PSA 1990 Vol. 2 Philosophy of Science Association East Lansing 79–93
A. Hastings et al. (1987) ArticleTitleChaos in ecology: is mother nature a strange attractor? Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 24 1–33
D. Hausman (1992) Why economists should look under the hood? In Essays on Philosophy and Economic Methodology Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Howard L.O. and Fiske W.F. 1991. The Importation into the United States of the Parasites of the Gypsy-Moth and the Brown-Tail Moth. US Department of AgricultureBureau of Entomology Bulletin 91.
P. Kareiva (1989) Renewing the dialogue between theory and experiments in population ecology J. Roughgarden R.M. May S.A. Levin (Eds) Perspectives in Ecological Theory Princeton University Press Princeton
S. Lawler (1993) ArticleTitleSpecies richness, species composition and population dynamics of protests in experimental microcosms J. Anim. Ecol. 62 711–719
Lawlor (1978) ArticleTitleA comment on randomly constructed model ecosystems Am. Nat. 112 445–447 Occurrence Handle10.1086/283286
S. Levin (1980) ArticleTitleMathematics, ecology, and orinthology Auk 97 422–425
S. Levin (1981) ArticleTitleThe role of theoretical ecology in the description and understanding of populations in heterogeneous environments Am. Zool. 21 865–875
R. Levins (1985) Qualitative Modeling of Complex Systems Harvard University Press Cambridge
R.M. May (1973) The Stability and Complexity of Model Ecosystems Princeton University Press Princeton
R.M. May (1974) ArticleTitleBiological populations with non-overlapping generations: stable points, stable cycles, and chaos Science 186 645–647 Occurrence Handle4412202
R.M. May (1975) ArticleTitleBiological populations obeying difference: stable points, stable cycles, and chaos J. Theor. Biol. 49 511–524 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0022-5193(75)90078-8
R.M. May (1976) ArticleTitleSimple models with very complicated dynamics Nature 261 459–467 Occurrence Handle10.1038/261459a0 Occurrence Handle934280
R.M. May (1981) ArticleTitleThe role of theory in ecology Am. Zool. 21 903–910
R.M May (2002) The best possible time to be alive: the logistic map G. Farmelo (Eds) It Must be Beautiful: Great Equations of Modern Science Granta Books London
R. May G. Oster (1976) ArticleTitleBifurcations and dynamic complexity in simple ecological models Am. Nat. 110 573–599 Occurrence Handle10.1086/283092
G. Mikkelson (1997) ArticleTitleMethods and metaphors in community ecology: the problem of defining stability Perspect. Sci. 5 481–498
M. Morgan M. Morrison (1999) Models as Mediators Cambridge University Press New York
A.J. Nicholson V.A. Bailey (1935) The Balance of Animal Populations, Part I Vol. 3 Proceedings of the Zoological Society London 551–598
G. Orians (1975) Diversity, stability, and maturity in natural ecosystems W.H. van Dobben R.H. Lowe-McConnel (Eds) Unifying Concepts in Ecology W. Junk The Hague 139–150
S. Orzack E. Sober (1994) ArticleTitleOptimality Models and the Tests of Adaptationism Naturalist 143 361–380 Occurrence Handle10.1086/285608
R.H. Peters (1991) A Critique for Ecology Cambridge University Press Cambridge
E.C. Pielou (1974) Population and Community Ecology: Principles and Methods Gordon and Breach Science Publishers New York
E.C. Pielou (1981) ArticleTitleThe usefulness of ecological models: a stock-taking Quart. Rev. Biol. 56 17–31 Occurrence Handle10.1086/412081
S. Pimm (1979) ArticleTitleComplexity and stability: Another look at MacArthur's original hypothesis Oikos 35 139–149
S. Pimm (1992) The Balance of Nature University of Chicago Press Chicago
J. Roughgarden (1979) The Theory of Population Genetics and Evolutionary Ecology Macmillan New York
J. Roughgarden (1984) ArticleTitleCompetition and theory in community ecology Am. Nat. 122 583–601 Occurrence Handle10.1086/284160
K. Shrader-Frechette E. McCoy (1993) Method in Ecology Cambridge University Press Cambridge
D. Simberloff (1981) ArticleTitleThe sick science of ecology Eidema 1 49–54
H.S. Smith (1935) ArticleTitleThe role of biotic factors in the determination of population densities J. Econ. Entomol. 28 873–898
E. Sober (1996) ArticleTitleEvolution and optimality—feathers, bowling balls, and the thesis of adaptationalism Philos. Exchange 6 41–57
M. Soule (1985) Population Viability Analysis Cambridge University Press Cambridge
D. Strong (1983) ArticleTitleNatural variability and the manifold mechanisms of ecological communities Am. Nat. 122 636–660 Occurrence Handle10.1086/284164
V. Volterra. 1926. Fluctuations in the Abundance of a Species Considered Mathematically. Nature 188
W. Wimsatt (1980) Reductionist research strategies and their biases in the units of selection controversy T. Nickles (Eds) Scientific Discovery: Case Studies Dordrecht Reidel
W. Wimsatt (1987) False Models as a Means to Truer Theories M. Nitecki A. Hoffman (Eds) Biology Oxford University Press Oxford 23–55
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Odenbaugh, J. Idealized, Inaccurate but Successful: A Pragmatic Approach to Evaluating Models in Theoretical Ecology. Biol Philos 20, 231–255 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-004-0478-6
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-004-0478-6