Abstract
The enactment of the Water Framework Directive (WFD) initiated scientific efforts to develop reliable methods for comparing prevailing lake conditions against reference (or nonimpaired) states, using the state of a set biological elements. Drawing a distinction between impaired and natural conditions can be a challenging exercise. Another important aspect is to ensure that water quality assessment is comparable among the different Member States. In this context, the present paper offers a constructive critique of the practices followed during the WFD implementation in Greece by pinpointing methodological weaknesses and knowledge gaps that undermine our ability to classify the ecological quality of Greek lakes. One of the pillars of WDF is a valid lake typology that sets ecological standards transcending geographic regions and national boundaries. The national typology of Greek lakes has failed to take into account essential components. WFD compliance assessments based on the descriptions of phytoplankton communities are oversimplified and as such should be revisited. Exclusion of most chroococcal species from the analysis of cyanobacteria biovolume in Greek lakes/reservoirs and most reservoirs in Spain, Portugal, and Cyprus is not consistent with the distribution of those taxa in lakes. Similarly, the total biovolume reference values and the indices used in classification schemes reflect misunderstandings of WFD core principles. This hampers the comparability of ecological status across Europe and leads to quality standards that are too relaxed to provide an efficient target for the protection of Greek/transboundary lakes such as the ancient Lake Megali Prespa.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arle J, Mohaupt V, Kirst I (2016) Monitoring of surface waters in Germany under the Water Framework Directive—a review of approaches, methods and results. Water 8:217
Baattrup-Pedersen A, Göthe E, Riis T, Andersen KD, Larsen ES (2017) A new paradigm for biomonitoring: an example building on the Danish Stream Plant Index. Methods Ecol Evol 8:297–307
Baattrup-Pedersen A, Larsen ES, Riis T (2013) From expert judgement to supervised classification: a new approach to assess ecological status in lowland streams. Sci Total Environ 447:116–122
Boeuf B, Fritsch O (2016) Studying the implementation of the Water Framework Directive in Europe: a meta-analysis of 89 journal articles. Ecol Soc 21:19
Brooks BW, Lazorchak JM, Howard MD, Johnson MV, Morton SL, Perkins DA, Reavie ED, Scott GI, Smith SA, Steevens JA (2016) Are harmful algal blooms becoming the greatest inland water quality threat to public health and aquatic ecosystems? Environ Toxicol Chem 35:6–13
Catalan J, Ventura M (2003) Desenvolupament d´un índex integral de qualitat ecológica iregionalizació ambiental dels sistemes lacustres de Catalunya. Agència Catalana de l´Aigua. Generalitat de Catalunya, Departament de Medi Ambient i Habitatge, Blanes. p. 177
Catsadorakis G (1997) The importance of Prespa National Park for breeding and wintering birds. In: Crivelli AJ, Catsadorakis G (eds) Lake Prespa, Northwestern Greece. Developments in Hydrobiology, vol 122, Springer, Dordrecht
Catsadorakis G, Onmus O, Bugariu S, Gül O, Hatzilacou D, Hatzofe O, Malakou M, Michev T, Naziridis T, Nikolaou H, Rudenko A, Saveljic D, Shumka S, Sıkı M, Crivelli A (2015) Current status of the Dalmatian pelican and the great white pelican populations of the Black Sea/Mediterranean flyway. Endanger Species Res 27:119–130
De Hoyos C, Catalán J, Dorflinger G, Ferreira J, Kemitzoglou D, Laplace-Treyture C, Pahissa J, Marchetto A, Mihail O, Morabito G, Polykarpou P, Romão F, Tsiaoussi V (2014) Water Framework Directive intercalibration technical report: Mediterranean lake phytoplankton ecological assessment methods. Publications Office of the European Union. https://circabc.europa.eu/webdav/CircaBC/env/wfd/Library/working_groups/ecological_status/05%20-%20Intercalibration%20of%20Ecological%20Status/Technical%20Reports%202013/Lakes%20-%20published%20technical%20reports/MEDITERRANEAN%20PHYTOPLANKTON%20METHODS%20-%20INTERCALIBRATION.pdf. Assessed 19 Nov 2017
Dillon PJ, Rigler FA (1975) A simple method for predicting the capacity of a lake for development based o lake trophic status. J Fish Res Board Can 32:1519–1531
Dimitriou E, Moussoulis E, Stamati F, Nikolaidis N (2009) Modelling hydrological characteristics of Mediterranean temporary ponds and potential impacts from climate change. Hydrobiologia 634:195–208
European Environment Agency (EEA) (2019) Biogeographical regions. EEA. https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/data/biogeographical-regions-europe-3#tab-data-visualisations. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
(EEA-ETC) European Environment Agency (2018) European waters Assessment of status and pressures 2018. EEA Report 7/2018. https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/state-of-water. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
European Commission (2000) Directive 2000/60/EC of the European parliament and of the council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for the Community action in the field of water policy. Official Journal of the European Communities L 327. European Commission, Brussels, pp. 1–72
European Commission (2008) Commission decision of 30 October 2008 establishing, pursuant to directive 2000/60/EC of the European parliament and of the council, the values of the Member State monitoring system classifications as a result of the intercalibration exercise (2008/915/EC). Official journal of the European union L 332/20. European Commission, Brussels
European Commission (2018) Commission Decision (EU) 2018/229 of 12 February 2018 establishing, pursuant to Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council, the values of the Member State monitoring system classifications as a result of the intercalibration exercise and repealing Commission Decision 2013/480/EU. Official Journal of the European Union L47/1. European Commission, Brussels
Fee JE (1979) A relation between lake morphometry and primary productivity and its use in interpreting whole-lake eutrophication experiments. Limnol Oceanogr 24:401–416
Grover J, Crane K, Baker J, Brooks B, Roelke D (2010) Spatial variation of harmful algae and their toxins in flowing-water habitats: a theoretical exploration. J Plankton Res 33:211–227
Guildford SJ, Hendzel LL, Kling HJ, Fee EJ, Robinson GGC, Hecky RE, Kasian SEM (1994) Effects of lake size on phytoplankton nutrient status. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 51:2769–2783
Hadjisolomou E, Stefanidis K, Papatheodorou G, Papastergiadou E (2018) Assessment of the eutrophication-related environmental parameters in two mediterranean lakes by integrating statistical techniques and self-organizing maps. Int J Environ Res Public Health 15:547. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph15030547
Hammer M, Balfors B, Mörtberg U, Petersson M, Quin A (2011) Governance of water resources in the phase of change: a case study of the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive in Sweden. Ambio 40:210–220
Hart RC, Wragg PD (2009) Recent blooms of the dinoflagellate Ceratium in Albert Falls Dam (KZN): history, causes, spatial features and impacts on a reservoir ecosystem and its zooplankton. Water SA 35:455–468
IUCN (2014) IUCN red list of threatened species. Version 2014.3. IUCN. https://www.iucnredlist.org/. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
Kang YK, Cho SY, Kang YH, Katano T, Jin ES, Kong DS, Han MS (2008) Isolation, identification and characterization of algicidal bacteria against Stephanodiscus hantzschii and Peridinium bipes for the control of freshwater winter algal blooms. J Appl Phycol 20:375–386
Katsiapi M, Michaloudi E, Moustaka-Gouni M, Pahissa Lopez J (2012) First ecological evaluation of the ancient Balkan Lake Megali Prespa based on plankton. J Biol Res Thessalon 17:51–56
Katsiapi M, Moustaka-Gouni M, Sommer U (2016) Assessing ecological water quality of freshwaters: PhyCoI—a new phytoplankton community Index. Ecol Inf 31:22–29
Kirillin G, Shatwell T (2016) Generalized scaling of seasonal thermal stratification in lakes. Earth Sci Rev 161:179–190
Krstić SS (2012) Environmental changes in lakes catchments as a trigger for rapid eutrophication—a prespa lake case study. In: Piacentini T, Miccadei E (eds) Studies on Environmental and Applied Geomorphology. InTech. https://doi.org/10.5772/27246
Lampert W, Sommer U (2007) Limnoecology. 2nd edn. Oxford University Press Inc, New York
Lepistö L, Rapala J, Lyra C, Berg KA, Erkomaa K, Issakainen J (2005) Occurrence and toxicity of cyanobacterial blooms dominated by Anabaena lemmermannii P. Richter and Aphanizomenon spp. in boreal lakes in 2003. Algol Stud 117:315–328
Lyche Solheim A, Austnes K, Globevnik L, Kristensen P, Moe SJ, Persson J, Phillips G, Poikane S, van de Bund W, Birk S (2019) A new broad typology for rivers and lakes in Europe: development and application for large-scale environmental assessments. Sci Tot Environ 697:134043
Lyche Solheim AL, Moe J, Persson J (2011) Task 2a: comparison of typologies. Bottom-up approach. Contract No. 070311/2011/603663/ETU/D1 “Comparative Study of Pressures and Measures in the Major River Basin Management Plans”. NIVA. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/archives/water/implrep2007/pdf/Task%202a%20Typology%20Report_bottom-up_final.pdf. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
Lyche Solheim AL, Phillips G, Drakare S, Free G, Järvinen M, Skjelbred B, Tierney D, Wayne T (2014) Water Framework Directive intercalibration technical report: Northern lake phytoplankton ecological assessment methods. Publications Office of the European Union. https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC88307/lb-na-26503-en-n.pdf. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
Löffler H, Schiller E, Kusel E, Kraill H (1998) Lake Prespa, a European natural monument, endangered by irrigation and eutrophication? Hydrobiologia 384:69–74
Maileht K, Nõges T, Nõges P, Ott I, Mischke U, Carvalho L, Dudley B (2013) Water colour, phosphorus and alkalinity are the major determinants of the dominant phytoplankton species in European lakes. Hydrobiologia 704:115–126
Marchetto A, Padedda BM, Mariani MA, Luglié A, Sechi N (2009) A numerical index for evaluating phytoplankton response to changes in nutrient levels in deep Mediterranean reservoirs. J Limnol 68:106–121
Matzinger A, Jordanoski M, Veljanoska-Sarafiloska E, Sturm M, Müller B, Wüest A (2006) Is Lake Prespa jeopardizing the ecosystem of ancient Lake Ohrid? Hydrobiologia 553:89–109
Mischke U, Riedmüller U, Hoehn E, Schönfelder I, Nixdorf B (2008) Description of the German system for phytoplankton-based assessment of lakes for implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive (WFD). In: Mischke U, Nixdorf B (eds), Gewässerreport 10, Aktuelle Reihe 2/2008. University Cottbus. pp. 117–146. http://opus.kobv.de/btu/volltexte/2009/953/. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
Moss B (2008) The Water Framework Directive: total environment or political compromise? Sci Total Environ 400:32–41
Moustaka-Gouni M (1993) Phytoplankton succession and diversity in a warm monomictic, relatively shallow lake: lake Volvi, Macedonia, Greece. Hydrobiologia 249:33–42
Moustaka-Gouni M, Michaloudi E, Sommer U (2014) Modifying the PEG model for the Mediterranean—no biological winter and strong fish predation. Freshw Biol 59:1136–1144
Moustaka-Gouni M, Nikolaidis G (1992) Phytoplankton and physical–chemical features of Tavropos Reservoir, Greece. Hydrobiologia 228:141–149
Nixon S, Bewes V, Mills D (2012) Study of pressures and measures in the major river basin management plans: comparison of typologies. Project report. WRc. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/archives/water/implrep2007/pdf/Governance-Pressures%20and%20measures.pdf. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
Onodera H, Oshima Y, Henriksen P, Yasumoto T (1997) Confirmation of anatoxin-a(s), in the cyanobacterium Anabaena lemmermannii, as the cause of bird kills in Danish Lakes. Toxicon 35:1645–1648
Ott I, Laugaste R (1996) Fütoplanktoni koondindeks (FKI), üldistus Eesti järvede kohta. Eesti Keskkonnaministeeriumi infoleht 3: 7–8 [The Phytoplankton Compound Quotient (PCQ) generalisation about Estonian small lakes. In Estonian]. Hydrobiologia 547:91–103
Pahissa J, Catalan J, Morabito G, Dörflinger G, Ferreira J, Laplace-Treyture C, Gîrbea R, Marchetto A, Polykarpou P, de Hoyos C (2015) Benefits and limitations of an intercalibration of phytoplankton assessment methods based on the Mediterranean GIG reservoir experience. Sci Total Environ 538:169–179
Papadimitriou T, Katsiapi M, Vlachopoulos K, Christopoulos A, Laspidou C, Moustaka-Gouni M, Kormas K (2018) Cyanotoxins as the “common suspects” for the Dalmatian pelican (Pelecanus crispus) deaths in a Mediterranean reconstructed reservoir. Environ Pollut 234:779–787
Pardo I, Poikane S, Bonne W (2011) Revision of the consistency in Reference Criteria application in the Phase I of the European Intercalibration exercise. JRC scientific and technical reports. http://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC65230/rc_tech%20report_fin_printversion.pdf. Accessed 2 Jan 2018
Peeters ETHM, Franken RJM, Jeppesen E, Moss B, Bécarese E, Hansson LA, Romo S, Kairesalo T, Gross EM, van Donk E, Nõges T, Irvine K, Kornijów R, Scheffer M (2008) Assessing ecological quality of shallow lakes: Does knowledge of transparency suffice? Basic Appl Ecol 10:89–96
Phillips G, Lyche Solheim A, Skjelbred B, Mischke U, Drakare S, Free G, Järvinen M, de Hoyos C, Morabito G, Poikane S, Carvalho L (2013) A phytoplanktontrophic index to assess the status of lakes for the Water Framework Directive. Hydrobiologia 704:75–95
Poikane S, Zampoukas N, Borja A, Davies SP, van de Bund W, Birk S (2014) Intercalibration of aquatic ecological assessment methods in the European Union: lessons learned and way forward. Environ Sci Policy 44:237–246
Popovska C, Bonacci O (2007) Basic data on the hydrology of Lakes Ochrid and Prespa. Hydrol Process 21:658–664
Ptacnik R, Solimini AG, Brettum P (2009) Performance of a new phytoplankton composition metric along a eutrophication gradient in Nordic lakes. Hydrobiologia 633:75–82
Read JS, Winslow LA, Hansen GJA, Van Den Hoek J, Hanson PC, Bruce LC, Markfort CD (2014) Simulating 2368 temperate lakes reveals weak coherence in stratification phenology. Ecol Model 291:142–159
Reynolds CS, Huszar V, Kruk C, Naselli-Flores L, Melo S (2002) Towards a functional classification of the freshwater phytoplankton. J Plankton Res 24:417–428
Salmaso N, Boscaini A, Capelli C, Cerasino L, Milan M, Putelli S, Tolotti M (2015) Historical colonisation patterns of Dolichospermum lemmermannii (Cyanobacteria) in a deep lake south of the Alps. Adv Oceanogr Limnol 6:1/2
Sommer U (1985) Comparison between steady state and non-steady state competition: experiments with natural phytoplankton. Limnol Oceanogr 30:335–346
Sommer U (1989) Nutrient status and nutrient competition of phytoplankton in a shallow, hypertrophic lake. Limnol Oceanogr 34:1162–1173
Sommer U, Gaedke U, Schweizer A (1993) The first decade of oligotrophication in Lake Constance. II: the response of phytoplankton taxonomic composition. Oecologia 93:276–284
Stamou G, Katsiapi M, Moustaka-Gouni M, Michaloudi E (2019) Grazing potential-a functional plankton food web metric for ecological water quality assessment in Mediterranean lakes. Water 11:1274. https://doi.org/10.3390/w11061274
Stoyneva M, Traykov I, Tosheva A, Uzunov B, Zidarova R, Descy JP (2015) Comparison of ecological state/potential assessment of 19 Bulgarian water bodies based on macrophytes and phytoplankton (2011–2012). Biotechnol Biotechnol Equip 29:S33–S38
Søndergaard M, Larsen SE, Johansson LS, Lauridsen TL, Jeppesen E (2016) Ecological classification of lakes: Uncertainty and the influence of year-to-year variability. Ecol Indic 61:248–257
Temponeras M, Kristiansen J, Moustaka-Gouni M (2000) Seasonal variation in phytoplankton composition and physical–chemical features of the shallow Lake Doirani, Macedonia, Greece. Hydrobiologia 424:109–122
Thienemann A (1925) Die Binnengenwässrer Mitteleuropas—eine limnologische Einführung. In: Thienemann A (ed) Die binnengewässer, stuttgart, schweizerbarth. pp. 199–207
Thienemann A (1927) Der Bau des Seebeckens in seiner Bedeutung für den Ablauf des Lebens im See. Verh Zool-Bot Ges Wien 77:87–91
Toomey AH (2016) What happens at the gap between knowledge and practice? Spaces of encounter and misencounter between environmental scientists and local people. Ecol Soc 21:28
Tryfon E, Moustaka-Gouni M, Nikolaidis G, Tsekos I (1994) I. Phytoplankton and physical-chemical features of the shallow Lake Mikri Prespa, Macedonia, Greece. Arch Hydrobiol 131:477–494
Veljanoska-Sarafiloska ME, Lokoska LS, Patceva SB (2019) Water quality of lakes ohrid and prespa based on physical-chemical and biological parameters in 2013–2014. Acta Zool Bulg Suppl 13:25–32
Vlachopoulou M, Coughlin D, Forrow D, Kirk S, Logan P, Voulvoulis N (2014) The potential of using the ecosystem approach in the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive. Sci Total Environ 470–471:684–694
Vollenweider RA, Kerekes J (1982) Eutrophication of waters, monitoring, assessment and control. OECD, Paris
Voulvoulis N, Arpon KD, Giakoumis T (2017) The EU Water Framework Directive: from great expectations to problems with implementation. Sci Total Environ 575:358–366
Wolfram G, Argillier C, De Bortoli J, Buzzi G, Dokulil MT, Hoehn E, Marchetto A, Martinez PJ, Morabito G, Reichmann M, Remec-Rekar Š, Riedmüller U, Rioury C, Schaumburg J, Schulz L, Urbani G (2009) Reference conditions and WFD compliant class boundaries for phytoplankton biomass and chlorophyll-a in Alpine lakes. Hydrobiologia 633:45–58
Wolfram G, Buzzi F, Dokulil M, Friedl F, Hoehn E, Laplace- Treyture C, Menay M, Marchetto A, Morabito G, Reichmann M, Remec-Rekar S, Riedmüller U, Urbanič G (2014) Water Framework Directive intercalibration technical report: alpine lake phytoplankton ecological assessment methods. Publications Office of the European Union. https://lakeohridniva.files.wordpress.com/2015/05/alpine-lake-phytoplankton.pdf. Accessed 19 Nov 2019
Acknowledgements
We thank the Special Secretariat for Waters, Ministry of Environment and Energy for providing to MM-G, member of the Greek National Committee for ecological classification, the lake data sets, the original physical-chemical, and phytoplankton data from the Greek NWMN.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Moustaka-Gouni, M., Sommer, U., Economou-Amilli, A. et al. Implementation of the Water Framework Directive: Lessons Learned and Future Perspectives for an Ecologically Meaningful Classification Based on Phytoplankton of the Status of Greek Lakes, Mediterranean Region. Environmental Management 64, 675–688 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-019-01226-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-019-01226-y